Faculty of Science and Literature, Department of Anthropology, Cumhuriyet University, Sivas, Turkey.
Am J Phys Anthropol. 2010 Oct;143(2):321-4. doi: 10.1002/ajpa.21357.
Fluctuating asymmetry (FA) is thought to increase as a result of environmental perturbations during development. A number of studies involving measures of health and developmental stability other than FA have discussed the presumed increased buffering in females relative to males. But, there is little evidence in the literature on FA to support this hypothesis. This research was conducted to determine the level of difference in terms of facial FA between sexes under different environmental conditions. Group 1 included final year students from three high schools in Yenimahalle, a slum district of Ankara (males: N = 163, mean age = 17.55, sd = 0.50; females: N = 141, mean age = 17.48, sd = 0.38). Group 2 included students with higher socioeconomic background and was composed of final year students from three different private schools located in Cankaya (N = 171, mean age = 17.44, sd = 0.26; females: N = 152, mean age = 17.38, sd = 0.31). Digital images were used to assess the degree of facial asymmetry as measured from eight paired traits and calculated as a composite score. The study shows that the male students had higher facial asymmetry than the female students. However, the present difference reaches a significant level in the low-socioeconomic status group. As a result, it could be inferred that differences in developmental stability between sexes might emerge under stressful conditions.
波动不对称(FA)被认为是由于发育过程中的环境干扰而增加的。许多涉及健康和发育稳定性的研究,除了 FA 之外,还讨论了女性相对于男性的假定增强缓冲作用。但是,关于 FA 的文献中几乎没有证据支持这一假设。本研究旨在确定在不同环境条件下,男女之间面部 FA 的差异程度。
第一组包括来自安卡拉 Yenicami 区(男性:N = 163,平均年龄 = 17.55,标准差 = 0.50;女性:N = 141,平均年龄 = 17.48,标准差 = 0.38)的三所高中的应届毕业生。第二组包括社会经济背景较高的学生,由位于 Cankaya 的三所不同私立学校的应届毕业生组成(男性:N = 171,平均年龄 = 17.44,标准差 = 0.26;女性:N = 152,平均年龄 = 17.38,标准差 = 0.31)。使用数字图像评估了从八个配对特征测量的面部不对称程度,并计算为综合得分。研究表明,男性学生的面部不对称程度高于女性学生。然而,目前的差异在低社会经济地位组中达到显著水平。因此,可以推断,在紧张的条件下,男女之间的发育稳定性差异可能会出现。