Medtronic Inc., Minneapolis, Minnesota 55432, USA.
Pain Med. 2010 Jul;11(7):1001-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1526-4637.2010.00889.x.
The authors recently determined that early and longer term mortality after initiation or reinitiation of intrathecal opioid therapy is higher than previously appreciated: 0.088% within 3 days, 0.39% at 1 month, and 3.89% at 1 year. These rates were 7.5 (confidence interval, 5.7-9.8), 3.4 (confidence interval, 2.9-3.8), and 2.7 (confidence interval, 2.6-2.8) times higher, respectively, at each interval than expected based on the age- and gender-matched general U.S. population. A substantial portion of this excess mortality is probably therapy related and cannot be entirely accounted for by underlying demographic or patient-related factors, or by device malfunctions. We also analyzed multiple complementary internal, governmental, and insurance databases to quantify mortality and to identify medical practice patterns that appear to be associated with patient mortality risks, and to suggest measures for physicians and health care facilities to consider in order to reduce those risks. Both of those objectives involve judgments, which may be controversial and are subject to practical limitations.
Multiple clinical and patient- or therapy-related factors appear to increase the risk for early post-implant mortality. Specific risk mitigation measures associated with each factor include: close attention to the starting intrathecal opioid dose (or restarting dose after therapy interruption); avoidance of outpatient implant or other device procedures that involve less than 24-hour monitoring for respiratory depression; supervision of concomitant opioid, respiratory depressant, or other central nervous system active drug intake early post-implant and chronically in the outpatient setting; and careful programming or dosage calculations and decisions in order to avoid the unintentional administration of high intrathecal opioid drug doses.
Mortality after initiation of or device interventions in intrathecal drug delivery patients appears to occur as a result of multiple factors that present possible mitigation opportunities for physicians and health care facilities.
作者最近发现,鞘内阿片类药物治疗开始或重新开始后早期和长期死亡率高于先前的认识:3 天内为 0.088%,1 个月时为 0.39%,1 年时为 3.89%。这些比率分别在每个时间间隔内高出 7.5(置信区间,5.7-9.8)、3.4(置信区间,2.9-3.8)和 2.7(置信区间,2.6-2.8)倍,这与基于年龄和性别匹配的美国普通人群相比。这种超额死亡率的很大一部分可能与治疗有关,不能完全归因于潜在的人口统计学或患者相关因素,或设备故障。我们还分析了多个内部、政府和保险数据库,以量化死亡率,并确定与患者死亡风险相关的医疗实践模式,并提出医生和医疗机构应考虑的措施,以降低这些风险。这两个目标都涉及判断,这些判断可能存在争议,并且受到实际限制。
多个临床和患者或治疗相关因素似乎增加了早期植入后死亡的风险。与每个因素相关的特定风险缓解措施包括:密切关注鞘内阿片类药物的起始剂量(或治疗中断后重新开始的剂量);避免门诊植入或其他设备程序,这些程序涉及不到 24 小时监测呼吸抑制;密切监测植入后和门诊慢性治疗期间同时使用的阿片类药物、呼吸抑制剂或其他中枢神经系统活性药物的摄入;以及仔细编程或剂量计算和决策,以避免意外给予高剂量鞘内阿片类药物。
鞘内药物输送患者开始治疗或进行设备干预后,死亡率似乎是由多个因素导致的,这为医生和医疗机构提供了可能的缓解机会。