Department of Health Economics and Epidemiology Research, School of Public Health, The University of Tokyo, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo, Japan.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2010 Jul 20;10:213. doi: 10.1186/1472-6963-10-213.
Very early rehabilitation is expected to improve functional outcomes after stroke, although its effectiveness has not been fully evaluated. The purpose of this study was to investigate the association between very early intervention (VEI), and patient outcomes at discharge by using nationwide large data and statistical treatment for selection bias.
In this study, we defined VEI as rehabilitation commencing within 3 days of stroke admission. The data were derived from a nationwide survey of acute-care hospitals conducted in 2007 for designing a reimbursement scheme and from a concurrent survey on rehabilitation services among a convenient subgroup of hospitals participating in the above survey. We included patients with a diagnosis code of ischaemic cerebrovascular disease with acute onset who underwent any rehabilitation services during hospitalisation. Surgery cases, those with no functional deficit, and those with a severe consciousness deficit upon admission were excluded. A total of 5,482 patients were enrolled from 294 hospitals. To correct for any potential selection bias, we used Friday admission as an instrumental variable (IV) and conducted a bivariate probit model analysis.
We found that VEI for acute stroke patients was significantly associated with a lesser degree of disability at discharge. Even after considering endogenous problems due to treatment selection, VEI improved the chance of reducing disability by 15.3% (p < 0.001). There was no significant association between VEI and in-hospital mortality, suggesting that VEI was not likely to lead to an adverse outcome.
These data suggest that VEI may lead to a better outcome with no increase in adverse events compared to delayed rehabilitation.
早期康复有望改善中风后的功能结局,但尚未充分评估其有效性。本研究旨在利用全国性大数据和统计处理方法来研究早期干预(VEI)与出院时患者结局之间的关系,以消除选择偏倚。
本研究将康复开始于中风入院后 3 天内定义为 VEI。数据来自于 2007 年为制定报销计划而进行的全国性急性护理医院调查,以及同时对参与上述调查的医院中方便抽样的康复服务进行的调查。我们纳入了诊断为急性发病的缺血性脑血管疾病且在住院期间接受任何康复服务的患者。排除手术病例、无功能缺陷病例以及入院时严重意识障碍病例。共从 294 家医院纳入了 5482 例患者。为了纠正任何潜在的选择偏倚,我们使用星期五入院作为工具变量(IV)并进行了双变量概率单位模型分析。
我们发现,急性中风患者的 VEI 与出院时残疾程度较轻显著相关。即使考虑到治疗选择引起的内生性问题,VEI 仍使残疾减少的机会增加了 15.3%(p<0.001)。VEI 与住院期间死亡率之间无显著关联,表明 VEI 不太可能导致不良结局。
与延迟康复相比,这些数据表明 VEI 可能会带来更好的结局,且不会增加不良事件。