Ewbank Michael P, Fox Elaine, Calder Andrew J
Medical Research Council Cognition and Brain Sciences Unit Cambridge, UK.
Front Hum Neurosci. 2010 Jul 7;4:56. doi: 10.3389/fnhum.2010.00056. eCollection 2010.
Behavioral evidence indicates that angry faces are seen as more threatening, and elicit greater anxiety, when directed at the observer, whereas the influence of gaze on the processing of fearful faces is less consistent. Recent research has also found inconsistent effects of expression and gaze direction on the amygdala response to facial signals of threat. However, such studies have failed to consider the important influence of anxiety on the response to signals of threat; an influence that is well established in behavioral research and recent neuroimaging studies. Here, we investigated the way in which individual differences in anxiety would influence the interactive effect of gaze and expression on the response to angry and fearful faces in the human extended amygdala. Participants viewed images of fearful, angry and neutral faces, either displaying an averted or direct gaze. We found that state anxiety predicted an increased response in the dorsal amygdala/substantia innominata (SI) to angry faces when gazing at, relative to away from the observer. By contrast, high state anxious individuals showed an increased amygdala response to fearful faces that was less dependent on gaze. In addition, the relationship between state anxiety and gaze on emotional intensity ratings mirrored the relationship between anxiety and the amygdala/SI response. These results have implications for understanding the functional role of the amygdala and extended amygdala in processing signals of threat, and are consistent with the proposed role of this region in coding the relevance or significance of a stimulus to the observer.
行为证据表明,愤怒的面孔在看向观察者时会被视为更具威胁性,并引发更大的焦虑,而注视对恐惧面孔加工的影响则不太一致。最近的研究还发现,表情和注视方向对杏仁核威胁面部信号反应的影响并不一致。然而,这类研究没有考虑到焦虑对威胁信号反应的重要影响;这种影响在行为研究和最近的神经影像学研究中已得到充分证实。在这里,我们研究了焦虑的个体差异如何影响注视和表情对人类扩展杏仁核中愤怒和恐惧面孔反应的交互作用。参与者观看了恐惧、愤怒和中性面孔的图像,这些面孔要么显示回避注视,要么显示直视。我们发现,状态焦虑预示着当面孔注视观察者而非看向别处时,背侧杏仁核/无名质(SI)对愤怒面孔的反应会增强。相比之下,高状态焦虑个体对恐惧面孔的杏仁核反应增强,且这种反应对注视的依赖性较小。此外,状态焦虑与注视对情绪强度评分的关系反映了焦虑与杏仁核/SI反应之间的关系。这些结果对于理解杏仁核和扩展杏仁核在处理威胁信号中的功能作用具有启示意义,并且与该区域在编码刺激对观察者的相关性或重要性方面的作用一致。