Dorman Tomasz, Sibiński Marcin, Kmieć Krzysztof, Bira Mirosław, Borowski Andrzej, Synder Marek
Department of Orthopaedics and Paediatric Orthopaedics, Medical University of Łódź.
Ortop Traumatol Rehabil. 2010 May-Jun;12(3):237-44.
The aim of the study was to analyse the outcomes of hip replacement complicated by intraoperative femoral fractures and to analyse their effective management.
The medical records of 43 cases of intraoperative femoral fractures (1.4% of all hip replacements) were retrospectively reviewed. The patient group included 29 females. Patients' age ranged from 20 to 66 years (mean age: 48.4 years). Follow-up duration ranged from 8 to 89 months (mean duration: 44 months).
There were 13 fractures of the greater trochanter, 21 fractures of the lesser trochanter involving the calcar, 7 at the implant stem level, and two below the implant stem. In 3 cases, the fracture was treated with a revision stem, with cerclage used in 17 other cases. In the remaining cases, the fractures were stable and did not require any internal fixation. Eighteen patients had very good final results, 19 had good and 6, fair results, according to Merle D'Aubigne- Postel's classification in Charnley's modification. None of our patients demonstrated evidence of stem loosening at the final follow-up.
Unstable intraoperative femoral fractures during a hip replacement procedure are rare and occur mostly in patients with post-dysplastic hips with a narrow intramedullary canal. In cases of stable fractures of the trochanter and calcar region, 12 weeks of partial weight bearing without additional immobilization is a sufficient approach. The final results are satisfactory in most cases of intraoperative femoral fractures.
本研究的目的是分析髋关节置换术中并发股骨骨折的结果,并分析其有效管理方法。
回顾性分析43例术中股骨骨折患者的病历(占所有髋关节置换术的1.4%)。患者组包括29名女性。患者年龄在20至66岁之间(平均年龄:48.4岁)。随访时间为8至89个月(平均时间:44个月)。
大转子骨折13例,小转子骨折累及股骨矩21例,假体柄水平骨折7例,假体柄以下骨折2例。3例骨折采用翻修柄治疗,其他17例采用环扎术。其余病例骨折稳定,无需任何内固定。根据Charnley改良版的Merle D'Aubigne-Postel分类,18例患者最终结果非常好,19例良好,6例一般。在最后一次随访中,我们的患者均未出现假体柄松动的迹象。
髋关节置换术中不稳定的股骨骨折很少见,主要发生在发育不良髋关节且髓腔狭窄的患者中。对于转子和股骨矩区域的稳定骨折,部分负重12周且无需额外固定是一种足够的方法。大多数术中股骨骨折的最终结果令人满意。