The University of Iowa, 361 Lindquist Center, Iowa City, IA 52242, USA.
Clin Psychol Rev. 2010 Dec;30(8):934-50. doi: 10.1016/j.cpr.2010.06.006. Epub 2010 Jun 25.
Low-income women have very high rates of depression and also face a number of unique barriers that can prevent them from seeking, accepting, engaging in, or benefiting from psychotherapy treatment. Untreated depression often leads to deleterious psychological consequences for these women and their children, and may also diminish a woman's ability to improve her economic circumstances. We reviewed the literature on psychotherapeutic interventions for depressed, low-income women, identifying a number of practical, psychological, and cultural barriers that often prevent them from engaging in psychotherapy. Next, we assessed the degree to which established intervention programs help women overcome these barriers. The data suggest that it is quite difficult to engage depressed, low-income women in psychotherapy, but that a number of standard psychotherapy approaches do show promise. However, we found that many of the currently available interventions fail to fully address the barriers that prevent this population from engaging in treatment. Moreover, the impact these interventions have on engagement and attrition rates or clinical improvements is often inadequately reported. We provide preliminary recommendations for clinicians who work with low-income women as well as suggestions for bolstering the literature base.
低收入女性的抑郁率非常高,同时还面临许多独特的障碍,这些障碍可能使她们无法寻求、接受、参与或受益于心理治疗。未经治疗的抑郁症常常给这些女性及其子女带来有害的心理后果,也可能削弱女性改善经济状况的能力。我们回顾了有关针对抑郁的低收入女性的心理治疗干预的文献,确定了一些实际的、心理的和文化的障碍,这些障碍常常使她们无法接受心理治疗。接下来,我们评估了既定的干预计划在帮助女性克服这些障碍方面的程度。数据表明,让抑郁的低收入女性接受心理治疗相当困难,但许多标准的心理治疗方法确实有希望。然而,我们发现,目前许多可用的干预措施并没有充分解决阻止这些人群接受治疗的障碍。此外,这些干预措施对参与率和流失率或临床改善的影响往往没有得到充分报告。我们为与低收入女性一起工作的临床医生提供了初步建议,并提出了加强文献基础的建议。