Department of General Surgery, Istanbul University, Istanbul School of Medicine, and Department of Cardiovascular Surgery, Siyami Ersek Chest, Heart and Vascular Surgery Training and Research Hospital, Istanbul, Turkey.
J Vasc Surg. 2010 Nov;52(5):1262-70. doi: 10.1016/j.jvs.2010.06.070. Epub 2010 Aug 21.
The present study was designed to evaluate the long-term efficacy and safety of once-daily enoxaparin plus warfarin for the outpatient ambulatory treatment of lower-limb deep venous thrombosis (DVT).
A total of 246 patients, comprising 128 men (mean age, 54.28±16.48 years) and 118 women (mean age, 50.11±16.47 years) with symptomatic lower extremity DVT, were included in this open-label, single-arm, multicenter, phase IV clinical trial conducted at 14 centers in Turkey. All patients were administered subcutaneous enoxaparin (1.5 mg/kg, once-daily) until international normalized ratio (INR) levels reached to 2 to 3, followed by oral warfarin (5 mg/d) for at least 3 months and elastic compression stockings (30-40 mm Hg). Clinical signs (leg circumference), symptoms (edema, pain, tenderness), recanalization rates upon duplex ultrasound examination, laboratory findings (D-dimer and INR levels), and postthrombotic syndrome status with CEAP classification were the efficacy parameters evaluated every 3 months during 18 months of follow-up. Safety end points included minor and major bleeding as well as serious adverse events.
Ambulatory treatment with enoxaparin plus warfarin significantly reduced physical symptoms, including tenderness, edema, pain (P<.001), and the circumference of the affected leg (P<.001). The leg circumference difference in almost all patients was <1.5 cm at the end of 18 months (P<.001). Recanalization rates for occluded iliofemoral vein were 76.1% at 3 months and 86.5% at 18 months (P<.001). An early and significant decrease obtained in D-dimer levels on day 10 continued to decline significantly until month 6 and remained unchanged afterwards (P<.001). Of four patients diagnosed with major bleeding during oral anticoagulant use, three recovered with conservative treatment (reduction in hemoglobin levels in 2 developed at visit 2 [day 10] and intracranial bleeding in 1 developed at visit 3 [day 30]), and one patient required a hysterectomy after menorrhagia developed at visit 7 (month 18). Two of the 65 (9.9%) adverse events documented were serious adverse events, but none of the serious adverse events leading to death were related to the study medications.
Ambulatory treatment with enoxaparin plus warfarin seems to be effective in symptomatic healing and in clinical improvement by reducing thrombus formation and organization at all levels of lower extremity venous system with DVT, without a significant major bleeding risk. Therefore, the results of our conventional conservative treatment are in line with 1A level evidence reported in the recent American College of Chest Physicians guideline.
本研究旨在评估依诺肝素钠一日一次联合华法林用于下肢深静脉血栓形成(DVT)门诊治疗的长期疗效和安全性。
土耳其 14 家中心开展了一项开放标签、单臂、多中心、IV 期临床试验,共纳入 246 例症状性下肢 DVT 患者(128 例男性,平均年龄 54.28±16.48 岁;118 例女性,平均年龄 50.11±16.47 岁)。所有患者接受依诺肝素钠(1.5mg/kg,每日一次)皮下注射,直至国际标准化比值(INR)达到 2 至 3,随后给予华法林(5mg/d)口服至少 3 个月,并使用弹性压缩袜(30-40mmHg)。在 18 个月的随访期间,每 3 个月评估一次临床体征(腿部周长)、症状(肿胀、疼痛、压痛)、双功超声检查的再通率、实验室检查(D-二聚体和 INR 水平)以及根据 CEAP 分类的血栓后综合征状态,作为疗效参数。安全性终点包括轻微和严重出血以及严重不良事件。
依诺肝素钠联合华法林的门诊治疗显著减轻了触痛、肿胀、疼痛(P<.001)和患侧腿部周长(P<.001)等躯体症状。18 个月时,几乎所有患者的腿部周长差均<1.5cm(P<.001)。3 个月时闭塞性髂股静脉再通率为 76.1%,18 个月时为 86.5%(P<.001)。第 10 天 D-二聚体水平显著下降,随后持续显著下降,直至 6 个月时保持不变(P<.001)。在使用口服抗凝剂期间,有 4 例患者被诊断为大出血,其中 3 例经保守治疗后恢复(2 例血红蛋白水平在第 2 次就诊时下降[第 10 天],1 例颅内出血在第 3 次就诊时下降[第 30 天]),1 例患者因月经过多在第 7 次就诊(第 18 个月)后需要进行子宫切除术。记录的 65 例(9.9%)不良事件中有 2 例为严重不良事件,但无严重不良事件导致死亡,且均与研究药物无关。
依诺肝素钠联合华法林的门诊治疗似乎有效,可通过降低下肢静脉系统各级血栓形成和组织形成来促进症状愈合和临床改善,且无明显大出血风险。因此,我们的常规保守治疗结果与近期美国胸科医师学会指南中报告的 1A 级证据一致。