Rodríguez Luna J M, Mayayo Dehesa T, Burgos Revilla J, Escudero Barrilero A
Servicio de Urología, Hospital Ramón y Cajal, Madrid, España.
Arch Esp Urol. 1990;43 Suppl 1:51-64.
The diagnostic error using classical methods in the staging of bladder tumors has been reported to range from 20 to 50%. With the advent of new diagnostic imaging techniques (CT and MRI) the accuracy rate has increased from 62% to 83%. Forty-eight patients with bladder tumors were submitted to a protocol correlating ultrasound (US), cytological and histopathological findings. Tumor staging was also performed by CT in 10 patients and by MRI in 3. Transurethral ultrasound distinguished the superficial from the infiltrating bladder tumors in 100% of the cases. The accuracy rate for US was greater than that of CT (90% versus 70%) and MRI although the difference was not statistically significant with respect to MRI. When cold biopsy was combined with transurethral US, the correlation of overall staging (level of infiltration and degree of non-differentiation) was 85% for the superficial tumors and 82.3% for the infiltrating tumors. Furthermore, no significant difference was observed between the cytological analyses of urine from micturition or lavage. Cytologically, the number of positives increased with the degree of tumor non-differentiation. These findings show that transurethral US combined with cold biopsy permits determining the stage as well as the degree of non-differentiation of the tumor with minimum error, which is crucial in determining the approach to tumor management utilizing the new treatment protocols for bladder carcinoma.
据报道,在膀胱肿瘤分期中使用传统方法的诊断错误率为20%至50%。随着新的诊断成像技术(CT和MRI)的出现,准确率已从62%提高到83%。48例膀胱肿瘤患者接受了一项将超声(US)、细胞学和组织病理学检查结果相关联的方案。10例患者通过CT进行肿瘤分期,3例通过MRI进行分期。经尿道超声在100%的病例中区分了浅表性和浸润性膀胱肿瘤。超声的准确率高于CT(90%对70%)和MRI,尽管与MRI相比差异无统计学意义。当冷活检与经尿道超声结合时,浅表性肿瘤的总体分期(浸润程度和未分化程度)相关性为85%,浸润性肿瘤为82.3%。此外,排尿或灌洗尿液的细胞学分析之间未观察到显著差异。在细胞学上,阳性数量随肿瘤未分化程度增加。这些发现表明,经尿道超声结合冷活检能够以最小的误差确定肿瘤的分期以及未分化程度,这对于利用膀胱癌新治疗方案确定肿瘤管理方法至关重要。