Department of Psychology, University of Warwick, Coventry CV4 7AL, United Kingdom.
J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2011 Feb;54(1):127-47. doi: 10.1044/1092-4388(2010/08-0148). Epub 2010 Aug 26.
Preschool children often have difficulties in word classification, despite good speech perception and production. Some researchers suggest that they represent words using phonetic features rather than phonemes. In this study, the authors examined whether there is a progression from feature-based to phoneme-based processing across age groups and whether responses are consistent across tasks and stimuli.
In Study 1, 120 three- to five-year-old children completed 3 tasks assessing use of phonetic features in classification, with an additional 58 older children completing 1 of the 3 tasks. In Study 2, all of the children, together with an additional adult sample, completed a nonword learning task.
In all 4 tasks, children classified words sharing phonemes as similar. In addition, children regarded words as similar if they shared manner of articulation, particularly word finally. Adults also showed this sensitivity to manner, but across the tasks, there was a pattern of increasing use of phonemic information with age.
Children tend to classify words as similar if they share phonemes or if they share manner of articulation word finally. Use of phonemic information becomes more common with age.
尽管学龄前儿童的言语感知和产生能力较好,但他们在单词分类上常常存在困难。一些研究人员认为,他们使用的是语音特征而不是音素来表示单词。在这项研究中,作者研究了年龄组之间是否存在从基于特征的处理向基于音素的处理的发展,以及在不同任务和刺激下的反应是否一致。
在研究 1 中,120 名 3 至 5 岁的儿童完成了 3 项任务,评估他们在分类中使用语音特征的情况,另外 58 名年龄较大的儿童完成了 3 项任务中的 1 项。在研究 2 中,所有的儿童,以及另外一组成人样本,都完成了一项非词学习任务。
在所有 4 项任务中,儿童都将具有相同音素的单词分类为相似。此外,如果单词具有相同的发音方式(尤其是最后一个单词),儿童也会将它们视为相似。成年人也表现出对发音方式的这种敏感性,但在不同的任务中,随着年龄的增长,对音素信息的使用呈现出增加的趋势。
如果单词共享音素或共享发音方式(尤其是最后一个单词),儿童往往会将它们分类为相似。随着年龄的增长,对音素信息的使用变得更加普遍。