Louët Estelle, Consoli Angèle, Lucanto Raffaella, Duplant Nicole, Bailly-Salin Marie-José, Lemoigne Annie, Martin Michèle, Mayer Charlotte, Thompson Caroline, Gollier-Briant Fanny, Laurent Claudine, Brunelle Julie, Bodeau Nicolas, Cohen David
Department of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, UPMC, APHP, GH Pitié-Salpétrière, Paris, France.
J Physiol Paris. 2010 Nov;104(5):257-62. doi: 10.1016/j.jphysparis.2010.08.004. Epub 2010 Sep 8.
Little is known concerning the prognostic significance of manic/mixed episodes in adolescents. In particular, whether the use of psychodynamic-oriented projective psychological testing predicts evolution to schizophrenia at follow-up has not been established. Eighty subjects, aged 12-20years old, consecutively hospitalized for a manic or mixed episode between 1994 and 2003 were recruited. All patients were contacted in 2005-2006 for a follow-up assessment. For the subgroup of adolescents (N=40) who had psychodynamic-oriented psychological testing (Rorschach and TAT), two scores regarding psychosocial risk and schizophrenia risk were computed using the clinical global impression (CGI) assessment based on an overall subjective rating given by a panel of expert psychologists who reviewed all protocols. At follow-up (average 8years), 25 (62.5%) patients, 16 females and nine males, were assessed: 14 still had a diagnosis of bipolar disorder; eight changed to schizo-affective disorder and three to schizophrenia. Inter-rater reliability of both CGI-risk scores (psychosocial risk and schizophrenia risk) showed good clinical consensus with intraclass correlation and Kappa scores ranging from 0.53 to 0.75. Univariate analysis showed that CGI-psychosocial risk score (p=0.017), type of index episode (p=0.049) and CGI-schizophrenia risk score (p=0.09) were associated with transition to schizophrenia spectrum disorder at follow-up. Age, sex, socioeconomic status, duration of stay and the presence of psychotic features at index episode were not associated with the transition. We conclude that the CGI assessment appears to be valid to score risk of poor outcome using psychodynamic-oriented psychological testing and that these scores may predict, in part, the transition to schizophrenia in adolescents with a history of manic/mixed episode.
关于青少年躁狂/混合发作的预后意义,人们所知甚少。特别是,以心理动力学为导向的投射性心理测试的使用是否能预测随访时向精神分裂症的演变尚未得到证实。招募了80名年龄在12至20岁之间、在1994年至2003年期间因躁狂或混合发作而连续住院的受试者。在2005年至2006年期间对所有患者进行了随访评估。对于接受了以心理动力学为导向的心理测试(罗夏墨迹测验和主题统觉测验)的青少年亚组(N = 40),基于一组专家心理学家审查所有记录后给出的总体主观评分,使用临床总体印象(CGI)评估计算了两个关于心理社会风险和精神分裂症风险的分数。在随访时(平均8年),对25名患者(16名女性和9名男性)进行了评估:14名仍被诊断为双相情感障碍;8名转变为精神分裂症性情感障碍,3名转变为精神分裂症。CGI风险分数(心理社会风险和精神分裂症风险)的评分者间信度在组内相关系数和Kappa分数从0.53至0.75之间显示出良好的临床一致性。单因素分析表明,CGI心理社会风险分数(p = 0.017)、索引发作类型(p = 0.049)和CGI精神分裂症风险分数(p = 0.09)与随访时向精神分裂症谱系障碍的转变相关。年龄、性别、社会经济地位、住院时间和索引发作时精神病性特征的存在与转变无关。我们得出结论,CGI评估似乎对于使用以心理动力学为导向的心理测试来评估不良结局风险是有效的,并且这些分数可能部分预测有躁狂/混合发作史的青少年向精神分裂症的转变。