Division of General Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD 21287, USA.
Trauma Violence Abuse. 2010 Oct;11(4):178-89. doi: 10.1177/1524838010379003.
Studies report that women use as much or more physical intimate partner violence (IPV) as men. Most of these studies measure IPV by counting the number of IPV acts over a specified time period, but counting acts captures only one aspect of this complex phenomenon. To inform interventions, women's motivations for using IPV must be understood. A systematic review, therefore, was conducted to summarize evidence regarding women's motivations for the use of physical IPV in heterosexual relationships. Four published literature databases were searched, and articles that met inclusion criteria were abstracted. This was supplemented with a bibliography search and expert consultation. Eligible studies included English-language publications that directly investigated heterosexual women's motivations for perpetrating nonlethal, physical IPV. Of the 144 potentially eligible articles, 23 met inclusion criteria. Over two thirds of studies enrolled participants from IPV shelters, courts, or batterers' treatment programs. Women's motivations were primarily assessed through interviews or administration of an author-created questionnaire. Anger and not being able to get a partner's attention were pervasive themes. Self-defense and retaliation also were commonly cited motivations, but distinguishing the two was difficult in some studies. Control was mentioned but not listed as a primary motivation. IPV prevention and treatment programs should explore ways to effectively address women's relationship concerns and ability to manage anger and should recognize that women commonly use IPV in response to their partner's violence.
研究报告称,女性使用的身体亲密伴侣暴力(IPV)与男性一样多或更多。这些研究大多数通过计算特定时间段内的 IPV 行为次数来衡量 IPV,但行为计数仅捕捉到这种复杂现象的一个方面。为了提供干预措施,必须了解女性使用 IPV 的动机。因此,进行了系统评价,以总结有关女性在异性恋关系中使用身体 IPV 的动机的证据。搜索了四个已发表的文献数据库,并摘录了符合纳入标准的文章。这通过书目搜索和专家咨询进行了补充。合格的研究包括直接调查异性恋女性实施非致命性、身体 IPV 的动机的英文出版物。在 144 篇可能符合条件的文章中,有 23 篇符合纳入标准。超过三分之二的研究招募了来自 IPV 庇护所、法院或施虐者治疗计划的参与者。女性的动机主要通过访谈或作者创建的问卷进行评估。愤怒和无法引起伴侣的注意是普遍存在的主题。自卫和报复也是常见的动机,但在一些研究中很难区分两者。控制被提及但未被列为主要动机。IPV 预防和治疗计划应探讨有效解决女性关系问题和管理愤怒能力的方法,并认识到女性通常会因伴侣的暴力而使用 IPV。