Department of Psychiatry and Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, and Division of Geriatric Psychiatry, Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Int Psychogeriatr. 2011 May;23(4):539-45. doi: 10.1017/S1041610210001535. Epub 2010 Sep 20.
Cholinesterase inhibitors (ChEIs) are being used for increasingly long periods of time, even in patients with severe Alzheimer's disease. Because there is little data to help clinicians to decide on when it is safe and appropriate to discontinue ChEIs after long-term use, practices may vary widely.
An internet-based survey was undertaken of Canadian dementia experts (geriatric psychiatrists, neurologists, geriatricians) involved in clinical trial research. Recommendations for ChEI discontinuation were determined based on responses to questions dealing with patient/caregiver preference, administrative considerations, effectiveness, and adverse events.
There was reasonable consensus that ChEIs should be discontinued based on patient and caregiver preference, and in the presence of severe bothersome adverse events. There was much less consensus on issues related to effectiveness - in particular, what constitutes greater than expected decline. There was a general reluctance to rely on any single measure of cognition, function and/or behavior, and in particular, the MMSE was seen as unhelpful for making decisions about discontinuation.
Recommendations for discontinuing ChEIs after long-term use from a survey of dementia experts are presented. Ideally, clinical practice guidelines based on controlled discontinuation trials are needed.
胆碱酯酶抑制剂(ChEIs)的使用时间越来越长,即使是在患有严重阿尔茨海默病的患者中也是如此。 由于几乎没有数据可以帮助临床医生决定在长期使用后何时安全且适当地停止使用 ChEIs,因此实践可能会有很大差异。
对参与临床试验研究的加拿大痴呆症专家(老年精神病学家、神经病学家、老年病学家)进行了基于互联网的调查。 根据处理患者/护理人员偏好、行政考虑、疗效和不良反应的问题的回答,确定了停止使用 ChEI 的建议。
人们普遍认为应该根据患者和护理人员的偏好以及严重的令人困扰的不良反应来停止使用 ChEI。 与疗效相关的问题的共识要少得多 - 特别是,什么构成了超出预期的下降。 人们普遍不愿意依赖任何单一的认知、功能和/或行为衡量标准,特别是 MMSE 被认为对做出停药决定没有帮助。
从对痴呆症专家的调查中提出了长期使用 ChEI 后停止使用的建议。 理想情况下,需要基于对照停药试验的临床实践指南。