de la Torre Carla L, Ramírez-Marrero Farah A, Martínez Lucía R, Nevárez Carmen
J Am Diet Assoc. 2010 Oct;110(10):1523-6. doi: 10.1016/j.jada.2010.07.006.
Equations to predict resting energy expenditure (REE) can be influenced by cultural and climatic factors. The purpose of this cross-sectional study was to evaluate the validity of the Harris-Benedict and Mifflin-St Jeor equations to predict REE in 48 healthy Puerto Rican adults (23 men, 25 women; aged 21 to 60 years, tested between January and March 2007) using indirect calorimetry as the criterion method for comparison. Weight, height, and skinfold thickness were measured. One-way analysis of variance was used to determine differences between the REE measured and predicted with the two equations, and independent t tests were used to detect differences between men and women. Linear and multiple regressions were conducted to determine relationships between the measured and predicted REE and to evaluate factors influencing REE. The REE predicted with Harris-Benedict and Mifflin-St Jeor were not statistically different from the REE measured with indirect calorimetry (mean±standard deviation: 1,555±268, 1,500±285, and 1,633±299 kcal/day, respectively; P=0.08). There was a strong correlation between the REE measured and predicted with Harris-Benedict and Mifflin-St Jeor (r=0.83, 0.87, respectively; P=0.0001). Mean REE was higher in men compared to women, and fat-free mass was the most influencing factor on REE. The Harris-Benedict and Mifflin-St Jeor are both valid equations for the prediction of REE in healthy Puerto Rican adults living in a tropical climate such as Puerto Rico. Both equations are appropriate for dietetics practitioners to use in assessing energy requirements in this population.
预测静息能量消耗(REE)的公式可能会受到文化和气候因素的影响。这项横断面研究的目的是评估Harris-Benedict方程和Mifflin-St Jeor方程在预测48名健康波多黎各成年人(23名男性,25名女性;年龄21至60岁,于2007年1月至3月进行测试)的REE时的有效性,采用间接测热法作为比较的标准方法。测量了体重、身高和皮褶厚度。采用单因素方差分析来确定用这两个公式测量和预测的REE之间的差异,并用独立t检验来检测男性和女性之间的差异。进行线性和多元回归以确定测量的和预测的REE之间的关系,并评估影响REE的因素。用Harris-Benedict方程和Mifflin-St Jeor方程预测的REE与用间接测热法测量的REE在统计学上没有差异(均值±标准差:分别为1,555±268、1,500±285和1,633±299千卡/天;P = 0.08)。用Harris-Benedict方程和Mifflin-St Jeor方程测量和预测的REE之间存在很强的相关性(r分别为0.83、0.87;P = 0.0001)。男性的平均REE高于女性,去脂体重是对REE影响最大的因素。Harris-Benedict方程和Mifflin-St Jeor方程对于预测生活在波多黎各这样的热带气候中的健康波多黎各成年人的REE都是有效的公式。这两个公式都适合饮食从业者用于评估该人群的能量需求。