Hassmann-Poznańska Elzbieta, Goździewski Artur, Piszcz Małgorzata, Skotnicka Bozena
Klinika Otolaryngologii Dzieciecej, Uniwersytetu Medycznego w Białymstoku.
Otolaryngol Pol. 2010 Jul-Aug;64(4):234-9. doi: 10.1016/S0030-6657(10)70022-6.
Otitis media with effusion is the most common cause of hearing loss in children and myringotomy with tympanostomy tube insertion is recommended procedure to deal with the problem. The objective of the present study was to determine the results of treatment, incidence and prevalence of middle ear sequelae and hearing results among children with chronic otitis media with effusion who received standard treatment with tympanostomy tubes.
The group of 97 patients treated by tympanostomy tubes insertion in the years 1999-2001 was reevaluated after mean period of follow up 7.3 years. At the control examination videootoscopy and audiologic examinations were performed. Audiological assessment consisted of tympanometry and pure-tone thresholds of air and bone conduction.
Recurrent otitis media with effusion requiring tube insertion occurred during follow up period in 23.7% of patients. At the control examination 16.5% of children had an ongoing otitis media or ventilation tube in place or tympanic membrane perforation. Most common tympanic membrane abnormality were focal atrophy (67.2% of ears) and myringosclerosis (39.5%) followed by retraction pockets of pars flaccida (29.9%) and tensa (9.6%). Mean pure-tone audiometric threshold were significantly higher in ears with tympanic membrane abnormality by the difference did not excide 5dB HL in ears with focal atrophy and myringosclerosis and 6.5 dB HL in ears with retraction pockets.
As the percentage of recurrences after tympanostomy tubes insertion are not uncommon prolonged period of follow up of those children is recommended. Although ventilation tubes have proven very effective in improving hearing in short term, they have not proven effective in preventing long-term sequelae of tympanic membrane and some degree of hearing loss. The decision about surgical treatment should be taken cautiously taking into account the chance of spontaneous resolution.
中耳积液是儿童听力损失的最常见原因,鼓膜切开术加置管术是处理该问题的推荐方法。本研究的目的是确定接受鼓膜置管标准治疗的慢性中耳积液儿童的治疗结果、中耳后遗症的发生率和患病率以及听力结果。
对1999年至2001年期间接受鼓膜置管术治疗的97例患者进行了平均7.3年的随访后重新评估。在对照检查中进行了视频耳镜检查和听力学检查。听力学评估包括鼓室导抗图以及气导和骨导纯音阈值。
随访期间,23.7%的患者出现了需要再次置管的复发性中耳积液。在对照检查中,16.5%的儿童患有持续性中耳炎或鼓膜置管在位或鼓膜穿孔。最常见的鼓膜异常是局灶性萎缩(占耳数的67.2%)和鼓膜硬化(39.5%),其次是松弛部内陷袋(29.9%)和紧张部内陷袋(9.6%)。鼓膜异常耳的平均纯音听力阈值明显更高,但局灶性萎缩和鼓膜硬化耳的差异不超过5dB HL,内陷袋耳的差异不超过6.5dB HL。
由于鼓膜置管术后复发的比例并不罕见,建议对这些儿童进行长期随访。虽然鼓膜置管在短期内已被证明对改善听力非常有效,但在预防鼓膜长期后遗症和一定程度的听力损失方面尚未被证明有效。在考虑自发缓解可能性的情况下,应谨慎做出手术治疗的决定。