Siegmund Berthold, Richter Heinrich, Pollmann Hartmut
Institut für Thrombophilie und Hämostaseologie, Münster, Germany.
Transfus Med Hemother. 2009;36(4):283-288. doi: 10.1159/000225965. Epub 2009 Jul 10.
A single centre study including 52 German patients aged ≥16 years with severe haemophilia A was performed to compare the amount of clotting factor and outcome between on-demand therapy (26 patients) and continuous prophylaxis (26 patients) over 1 year. RESULTS: Prophylaxis reduced the number of bleeds significantly. Compared to on-demand treatment (20.5 ± 3.0 bleeds/year/patient), under prophylaxis 7.8 ± 1.3 bleeds/year/patient were observed. Joint bleeds were reduced from 12.2 ± 1.5 to 4.7 ± 1.0/year/ patient. In the on-demand group 38% of the patients suffered from more than 2 bleeds/month, whereas in the prophylaxis group no patient was found with more than 2 bleeds/month. Mean annual factor VIII (FVIII) consumption increased from 767 ± 110 IU/kg body weight under on-demand treatment to 2,841 ± 341 IU/kg body weight under continuous prophylaxis, displaying a nearly fourfold increase in FVIII consumption. Furthermore, prophylaxis implies a more than four-fold increase in treatment days which escalated from a mean weekly injection rate of 0.56 ± 0.08 FVIII injections/week when bleeds were treated on demand to 2.52 ± 0.30 FVIII injections/week during prophylaxis. CONCLUSION: Even though the results reflect a benefit also for prophylactically treated patients regarding their bleeding frequency, one has to take into account a substantial increase of the costs for coagulation concentrates when all patients with severe haemophilia A switch to continuous prophylaxis.
开展了一项单中心研究,纳入52名年龄≥16岁的重度甲型血友病德国患者,以比较按需治疗组(26例患者)和持续预防组(26例患者)在1年时间内的凝血因子用量及治疗结果。结果:预防治疗显著减少了出血次数。与按需治疗相比(20.5±3.0次出血/年/患者),预防治疗组观察到每年7.8±1.3次出血/患者。关节出血从每年12.2±1.5次降至4.7±1.0次/患者。在按需治疗组中,38%的患者每月出血超过2次,而在预防治疗组中,未发现有患者每月出血超过2次。平均每年的凝血因子VIII(FVIII)用量从按需治疗时的767±110 IU/kg体重增加到持续预防时的2841±341 IU/kg体重,FVIII用量增加了近四倍。此外,预防治疗意味着治疗天数增加了四倍多,从按需治疗出血时平均每周注射率0.56±0.08次FVIII注射/周增加到预防治疗期间的2.52±0.30次FVIII注射/周。结论:尽管结果显示预防治疗的患者在出血频率方面也有获益,但当所有重度甲型血友病患者都转为持续预防治疗时,必须考虑到凝血浓缩剂成本的大幅增加。