Center for Health Policy/Primary Care and Outcomes Research, Stanford University School of Medicine, Palo Alto, CA, USA.
Ann Emerg Med. 2011 Feb;57(2):104-108.e2. doi: 10.1016/j.annemergmed.2010.07.015.
We describe the availability of preventive health services in US emergency departments (EDs), as well as ED directors' preferred service and perceptions of barriers to offering preventive services.
Using the 2007 National Emergency Department Inventory (NEDI)-USA, we randomly sampled 350 (7%) of 4,874 EDs. We surveyed directors of these EDs to determine the availability of (1) screening and referral programs for alcohol, tobacco, geriatric falls, intimate partner violence, HIV, diabetes, and hypertension; (2) vaccination programs for influenza and pneumococcus; and (3) linkage programs to primary care and health insurance. ED directors were asked to select the service they would most like to implement and to rate 5 potential barriers to offering preventive services.
Two hundred seventy-seven EDs (80%) responded across 46 states. Availability of services ranged from 66% for intimate partner violence screening to 19% for HIV screening. ED directors wanted to implement primary care linkage most (17%) and HIV screening least (2%). ED directors "agreed/strongly agreed" that the following are barriers to ED preventive care: cost (74%), increased patient length of stay (64%), lack of follow-up (60%), resource shifting leading to worse patient outcomes (53%), and philosophical opposition (27%).
Most US EDs offer preventive services, but availability and ED director preference for type of service vary greatly. The majority of EDs do not routinely offer Centers for Disease Control and Prevention-recommended HIV screening. Most ED directors are not philosophically opposed to offering preventive services but are concerned with added costs, effects on ED operations, and potential lack of follow-up.
我们描述了美国急诊部(ED)提供预防保健服务的情况,以及 ED 主任对提供预防服务的首选服务和看法的障碍。
我们使用 2007 年国家急诊部清单(NEDI)-美国,随机抽取了 4874 个 ED 中的 350 个(7%)。我们调查了这些 ED 的主任,以确定(1)酒精、烟草、老年跌倒、亲密伴侣暴力、艾滋病毒、糖尿病和高血压的筛查和转介计划;(2)流感和肺炎球菌疫苗接种计划;(3)与初级保健和医疗保险的联系计划。ED 主任被要求选择他们最想实施的服务,并对提供预防服务的 5 个潜在障碍进行评级。
来自 46 个州的 277 个 ED(80%)做出了回应。服务的可用性范围从亲密伴侣暴力筛查的 66%到艾滋病毒筛查的 19%。ED 主任最想实施初级保健联系(17%)和艾滋病毒筛查最少(2%)。ED 主任“同意/强烈同意”,以下是 ED 预防保健的障碍:成本(74%)、患者住院时间延长(64%)、缺乏后续行动(60%)、资源转移导致患者预后恶化(53%)和哲学反对(27%)。
大多数美国 ED 提供预防服务,但可用性和 ED 主任对服务类型的偏好差异很大。大多数 ED 不常规提供疾病控制和预防中心推荐的艾滋病毒筛查。大多数 ED 主任并不是从哲学上反对提供预防服务,而是担心增加成本、对 ED 运营的影响以及潜在的缺乏后续行动。