Chen Alan A, Marucho Marcelo, Baker Nathan A, Pappu Rohit V
Computational and Molecular Biophysics Program, Washington University in St. Louis, St. Louis, Missouri, USA.
Methods Enzymol. 2009;469:411-32. doi: 10.1016/S0076-6879(09)69020-0. Epub 2009 Nov 17.
RNA folding and binding reactions are mediated by interactions with ions that make up the surrounding aqueous electrolytic milieu. Although Mg(2+) ions are often implicated as being crucial for RNA folding, it is known that folding is feasible in high concentrations of monovalent alkali-halide salts. Experiments have yielded important information regarding the salt dependence of RNA stability. Recent work has shown that molecular simulations based on explicit representations of solvent molecules and monovalent ions can also provide useful insights regarding the ionic atmospheres around model RNA systems. These insights can help rationalize intriguing observations regarding the dependence of RNA stability on cation type providing one pays attention to important considerations that go into the proper design of molecular simulations. These issues are discussed in detail and the methods are applied to an A-form RNA and B-form DNA sequence. The results of these simulations are compared to previous work on a kissing-loop system with analogous sequence. In particular, ionic atmospheres obtained from molecular simulations are compared to those obtained using the nonlinear Poisson Boltzmann model for continuum electrostatics for these three different nucleic acid systems. The comparisons indicate reasonable agreement in terms of coarse-grained observables such as the numbers of counterions accumulated around the solutes. However, details of the ionic atmospheres, captured in terms of spatial free energy density profiles, are quite different between the two approaches. These comparisons suggest the need for improvements in continuum models to capture sequence-specific effects, ion-ion correlation, and the effects of partial dehydration of ions.
RNA折叠和结合反应是由与构成周围水性电解质环境的离子相互作用介导的。尽管镁离子(Mg²⁺)通常被认为对RNA折叠至关重要,但已知在高浓度的单价碱金属卤化物盐中折叠是可行的。实验已经得出了关于RNA稳定性的盐依赖性的重要信息。最近的研究表明,基于溶剂分子和单价离子的明确表示的分子模拟,也可以提供有关模型RNA系统周围离子氛围的有用见解。这些见解有助于解释关于RNA稳定性对阳离子类型依赖性的有趣观察结果,前提是要注意分子模拟正确设计中涉及的重要考虑因素。本文将详细讨论这些问题,并将这些方法应用于一个A-form RNA和B-form DNA序列。将这些模拟结果与先前对具有类似序列的亲吻环系统的研究进行比较。特别是,将从分子模拟中获得的离子氛围与使用非线性泊松玻尔兹曼连续静电模型为这三种不同核酸系统获得的离子氛围进行比较。比较结果表明,在诸如溶质周围积累的抗衡离子数量等粗粒度可观测值方面,两者具有合理的一致性。然而,就空间自由能密度分布而言,两种方法捕获的离子氛围细节有很大不同。这些比较表明,需要改进连续介质模型,以捕获序列特异性效应、离子-离子相关性以及离子部分脱水的影响。