Department of Chest Medicine, Hôpital du Sacré-Coeur de Montréal, 5400 Gouin Blvd West, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
Occup Environ Med. 2011 Apr;68(4):302-7. doi: 10.1136/oem.2010.055129. Epub 2010 Oct 15.
Surveillance programmes for occupational asthma should reduce the severity of asthma both at the time of diagnosis and after removal from exposure as well as costs related to functional impairment. The aim of this study was to compare the severity and cost of diisocyanate-induced occupational asthma in workers participating in a surveillance programme and in twice the number of workers diagnosed after being referred by their physician.
Answers to a self-administered questionnaire led to possible referral for further assessment that included methacholine testing and specific inhalation challenges as the gold standard for confirming occupational asthma. Results Of the 2897 workers who participated, 182 (6.3%) had a positive questionnaire. 79/182 (43%) were referred for further medical assessment and 20 had confirmed occupational asthma by specific inhalation testing. At the time of diagnosis, the 20 screened subjects had a mean PC(20) of 3.35 mg/ml as compared to 1.50 mg/ml (p = 0.05) in the 66 controls. Two years after diagnosis and removal from exposure, the 20 subjects screened had a mean PC(20) of 4.81 mg/ml compared to 1.67 mg/ml (p = 0.03) in controls. Clinical remission occurred in 34% of the screened group compared to 16% of the control group (p = 0.02). The median costs for functional impairment were $C11,900 in screened subjects and $C19,600 in controls (p = 0.04).
Subjects with occupational asthma screened by a medical surveillance programme have a better outcome both at the time of diagnosis and 2 years after removal from exposure, with lower compensation costs compared to controls.
职业性哮喘的监测计划应降低哮喘的严重程度,无论是在诊断时还是在接触暴露后,以及与功能障碍相关的成本。本研究的目的是比较参与监测计划的工人和因医生转介而被诊断出的两倍工人的异氰酸酯引起的职业性哮喘的严重程度和成本。
对自我管理问卷的回答导致可能需要进一步评估,包括乙酰甲胆碱测试和特异性吸入挑战作为确认职业性哮喘的金标准。结果:在 2897 名参与的工人中,182 人(6.3%)问卷呈阳性。182 人中的 79 人(43%)被转介进行进一步的医学评估,20 人通过特异性吸入测试确诊为职业性哮喘。在诊断时,20 名筛查对象的 PC(20)平均为 3.35mg/ml,而 66 名对照对象的 PC(20)平均为 1.50mg/ml(p=0.05)。在诊断和接触暴露后两年,20 名筛查对象的 PC(20)平均为 4.81mg/ml,而对照对象的 PC(20)平均为 1.67mg/ml(p=0.03)。筛查组中有 34%的患者出现临床缓解,而对照组为 16%(p=0.02)。筛查组的功能障碍补偿中位数为 11900 加元,对照组为 19600 加元(p=0.04)。
通过医疗监测计划筛查出的职业性哮喘患者,无论是在诊断时还是在接触暴露后 2 年,都有更好的结果,与对照组相比,补偿费用更低。