Kuthy Raymond A, McQuistan Michelle R, Heller Keith E, Riniker-Pins Katharine J, Qian Fang
Department of Preventive and Community Dentistry, University of Iowa College of Dentistry, Iowa City, Iowa, USA.
Spec Care Dentist. 2010 Nov-Dec;30(6):242-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1754-4505.2010.00161.x. Epub 2010 Oct 19.
The purpose of this study was to compare the perceived change in comfort level and future willingness of senior dental students toward treating 12 different groups of traditionally underserved populations. Written surveys of senior dental students were conducted prior to and after completing extramural clinical rotations. A Likert-type scale was used to assess student comfort, whereas future willingness to treat these populations was dichotomous. Over a 13-year period (1992-2004), 560 students completed both surveys. There was an improvement in students' comfort level for 7 of 12 groups after the community-based assignments, yet there were no differences among population groups based on students' gender or assignments. There were positive changes for future willingness to treat patients who were mentally compromised, homeless, and non-English speaking, while there was a negative change for treating patients who were frail and elderly and those who were HIV+ or had AIDS. Students with improved comfort levels were more apt to be willing to treat patients who were frail elderly, medically complex, mentally compromised, and non-English speaking in the future. While student comfort in treating several groups improved after completion of the community-based experiences, there were mixed results for future willingness to treat underserved populations.
本研究的目的是比较高年级牙科学生在治疗12个不同的传统上服务不足群体时所感受到的舒适度变化以及未来的治疗意愿。在完成校外临床轮转之前和之后,对高年级牙科学生进行了书面调查。采用李克特量表来评估学生的舒适度,而未来治疗这些群体的意愿则采用二分法。在13年期间(1992 - 2004年),560名学生完成了这两项调查。在基于社区的任务完成后,12个群体中有7个群体的学生舒适度有所提高,但基于学生的性别或任务,各群体之间没有差异。对于治疗精神有问题、无家可归和非英语患者的未来意愿有积极变化,而对于治疗体弱和老年患者以及艾滋病毒阳性或患有艾滋病的患者的未来意愿有消极变化。舒适度提高的学生在未来更倾向于愿意治疗体弱的老年患者、医疗情况复杂的患者、精神有问题的患者和非英语患者。虽然在完成基于社区的经历后,学生在治疗几个群体时的舒适度有所提高,但在未来治疗服务不足群体的意愿方面,结果喜忧参半。