Inamdar S Noorein, Osland Asbjorn, Wells Pam
Organization and Management, San Jose State University, California, USA.
Health Care Manag (Frederick). 2010 Oct-Dec;29(4):305-17. doi: 10.1097/HCM.0b013e3181fa0278.
The strategic roles enabling conditions and intermediate outcomes of middle managers during a period of organizational restructuring were examined, with focus on developing an understanding of how senior management can best enable middle managers to achieve radical change. The case method was used, and data were collected from interviews with both middle and senior managers. Results revealed considerable differences between executives and middle managers with regard to middle management's strategic roles, enabling conditions and outcomes. Findings suggest that the 2 groups have different perceptions on how best to support middle management in strategic roles, especially during a crisis. Senior managers felt that middle managers required much explanation and guidance concerning the restructuring effort, viewing middle managers as primarily implementers. Middle managers viewed themselves in a more active role as providers of information necessary in guiding the restructuring decisions. In the area of intermediate outcomes, senior managers emphasized gaining consensus from middle managers to support implementation, but middle managers valued the outcome of securing agency over their own work to act in the best interests of the organization. Thus, middle managers can add value during a time of restructuring by matching strategic roles, enabling conditions and intermediate outcomes with the requirements of the strategic change.
研究了组织重组期间中层管理人员的战略角色、促成条件和中间结果,重点是深入了解高层管理人员如何才能最好地促使中层管理人员实现根本性变革。采用了案例研究法,通过对中层和高层管理人员的访谈收集数据。结果显示,在中层管理的战略角色、促成条件和结果方面,高管与中层管理人员之间存在相当大的差异。研究结果表明,两组人员对于如何最好地支持中层管理人员发挥战略作用,尤其是在危机期间,看法不同。高层管理人员认为,中层管理人员在重组工作方面需要大量解释和指导,将中层管理人员主要视为执行者。中层管理人员则认为自己在指导重组决策所需信息的提供方面发挥着更积极的作用。在中间结果方面,高层管理人员强调从中层管理人员那里获得支持实施的共识,但中层管理人员重视获得对自身工作的自主权这一结果,以便为组织的最佳利益行事。因此,在重组期间,中层管理人员可以通过使战略角色、促成条件和中间结果与战略变革的要求相匹配来增加价值。