NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow, UK.
J Psychiatr Ment Health Nurs. 2010 Oct;17(8):706-14. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2850.2010.01585.x. Epub 2010 Jun 22.
Scotland has a national programme to improve mental health and well-being and addressing stigma among mental health practitioners is a priority. This study explores practitioner attitudes towards patients in medium and low secure forensic mental health settings through qualitative and quantitative approaches. Two questionnaires were used with nursing staff. A qualitative questionnaire asked participants to list examples of positive and negative practice and anti-discriminatory and discriminatory attitudes towards patients within forensic services. A quantitative questionnaire then asked participants to answer questions about a hypothetical man with schizophrenia called Harry. The overall balance of responses was more positive than negative in the qualitative results, particularly regarding patient rights, empowerment and control. However, there were a significant minority of negative attitudes in relation to recovery pessimism and desire for social distance. This was supported by the quantitative results where practitioners showed high stigma scores for avoidance and segregation. There were no significant differences in attitudes between medium and low secure settings. However overall, males reported more negative attitudes in relation to blame and avoidance and younger participants demonstrated more negative attitudes than older participants in relation to fear and danger. The implications for addressing stigma are discussed in relation to the wider national anti-stigma campaign and forensic services specifically.
苏格兰有一个改善心理健康和福祉的国家计划,解决心理健康从业者的污名问题是当务之急。本研究通过定性和定量方法探讨了中低安全度法医心理健康环境中从业者对患者的态度。使用了两份问卷对护理人员进行调查。定性问卷要求参与者列出法医服务中对患者的积极和消极实践以及反歧视和歧视态度的例子。然后,定量问卷要求参与者回答关于一个名叫哈利的患有精神分裂症的虚构男性的问题。定性结果中,整体的反应是积极的多于消极的,特别是在患者权利、赋权和控制方面。然而,在恢复悲观主义和希望保持社会距离方面,仍存在少数人持消极态度。定量结果也支持这一观点,从业者在回避和隔离方面的污名得分较高。在中低安全环境之间,态度没有显著差异。然而,总体而言,男性在责备和回避方面表现出更多的消极态度,而年轻参与者在恐惧和危险方面表现出比年长参与者更多的消极态度。本文讨论了在更广泛的国家反污名运动和法医服务中解决污名问题的意义。