School of Nursing, King's College London, London.
Br J Gen Pract. 2010 Nov;60(580):822-8. doi: 10.3399/bjgp10X532602.
Timely antenatal sickle cell and thalassaemia (SC&T) screening for all women in primary care facilitates informed decision making, but little is known about its implementation.
To assess the feasibility of offering antenatal SC&T screening in primary care at the time of pregnancy confirmation.
Cross-sectional investigation of GPs' beliefs and perceived practices.
Informal face-to-face interviews with 34 GPs.
Seventeen inner-city general practices that offered antenatal SC&T screening as part of a trial.
GPs identified both barriers and facilitators. Organisational barriers included inflexible appointment systems and lack of interpreters for women whose first language was not English. Professional barriers included concerns about raising possible adverse outcomes in the first antenatal visit. Perceived patient barriers included women's lack of awareness of SC&T. Hence, GPs presented the test to women as routine, rather than as a choice. Organisational facilitators included simple and flexible systems for offering screening in primary care, practice cohesion, and training. Professional facilitators included positive attitudes to screening for SC&T. Perceived patient facilitators included women's desire for healthy children.
GPs reported barriers, as well as facilitators, to successful implementation but the extent to which screening could be regarded as offering 'informed choice' remained fundamental when making sense of these barriers and facilitators.
在初级保健中及时对所有女性进行镰状细胞病和地中海贫血症(SCT)筛查,有助于做出明智的决策,但对其实施情况知之甚少。
评估在妊娠确认时在初级保健中提供 SCT 产前筛查的可行性。
对全科医生的信念和感知实践进行横断面调查。
对 34 名全科医生进行非正规的面对面访谈。
17 家位于市中心的普通诊所,这些诊所提供 SCT 产前筛查作为一项试验的一部分。
全科医生确定了障碍和促进因素。组织障碍包括预约系统缺乏灵活性,以及对第一语言不是英语的女性缺乏口译员。专业障碍包括担心在第一次产前检查中提出可能的不良后果。感知到的患者障碍包括女性对 SCT 的认识不足。因此,医生将该测试呈现为常规检查,而不是一种选择。组织促进因素包括在初级保健中提供筛查的简单灵活的系统、实践凝聚力和培训。专业的促进因素包括对 SCT 筛查的积极态度。感知到的患者促进因素包括女性对健康孩子的渴望。
全科医生报告了成功实施的障碍和促进因素,但在理解这些障碍和促进因素时,筛查是否可以被视为提供“知情选择”仍然是至关重要的。