Department of Radiology, Veterans Administration Medical Center, 3350 La Jolla Village Dr, San Diego, CA 92161, USA.
Eur J Radiol. 2011 Feb;77(2):215-21. doi: 10.1016/j.ejrad.2010.10.015. Epub 2010 Nov 10.
To determine the accuracy of ultrasonography (US) in the evaluation of degenerative changes in the distal radioulnar joint (DRUJ).
Ten cadaveric specimens were obtained. US evaluation of cartilage degeneration and thickness was performed by two independent and blinded readers (R1 and R2). Gross anatomy and MR arthrography evaluated by two readers in consensus served as the reference standard. The joint surface not accessible to US was measured.
US interreader agreement was non-existent for cartilage thickness measurements and moderate for cartilage degeneration grading (weighted kappa = 0.41). Comparing US and MR imaging evaluation, there was no correlation between US R1 and MR imaging (Pearson correlation coefficient [PCC] = 0.352) and a moderate correlation between US R2 and MR imaging (PCC = 0.570) concerning cartilage thickness measurements. Concerning cartilage degeneration grading, there was a moderate to strong (R1 Spearman correlation coefficient [SCC] = 0.729)/R2 SCC = 0.767) correlation concerning cartilage degeneration grading. Comparing US and gross anatomic evaluation, there was no correlation for US R1 (PCC = 0.220) and a strong correlation for US R2 (PCC = 0.922) concerning cartilage thickness measurements, and a strong to moderate correlation (R1 SCC = 0.808/R2 SCC = 0.597) concerning cartilage degeneration grading. The mean sector of the articular surface of the ulna head not accessible to US was 13°.
In conclusion the DRUJ is accessible to US except in the central 13° sector of the joint surface. US was approved to be sufficient in demonstrating advanced stages of cartilage degeneration. Thus, US of the DRUJ is recommended in patients suffering from ulnar-sided wrist pain.
确定超声(US)在评估远侧桡尺关节(DRUJ)退行性变化中的准确性。
共获得 10 个尸体标本。由两名独立且盲法的读者(R1 和 R2)进行 US 评估软骨退变和厚度。两名读者一致评估的大体解剖和 MR 关节造影术作为参考标准。无法进行 US 测量的关节面。
US 两名读者之间的一致性对于软骨厚度测量为不存在,而对于软骨退变分级为中度(加权κ=0.41)。与 US 和 MR 成像评估相比,US R1 与 MR 成像之间无相关性(Pearson 相关系数[PCC]=0.352),而 US R2 与 MR 成像之间具有中度相关性(PCC=0.570)对于软骨厚度测量。就软骨退变分级而言,US R1 具有中度至强(R1 Spearman 相关系数[SCC]=0.729)/R2 SCC=0.767)相关性,R2 具有中度至强(R1 SCC=0.729)/R2 SCC=0.767)相关性)。与大体解剖评估相比,US R1 之间无相关性(PCC=0.220),US R2 之间有很强的相关性(PCC=0.922)对于软骨厚度测量,而对于软骨退变分级具有很强到中度的相关性(R1 SCC=0.808/R2 SCC=0.597)。无法进行 US 测量的尺骨小头关节面的平均扇形区为 13°。
DRUJ 可通过 US 检查,但关节面的中心 13°区域除外。US 被证明足以显示软骨退变的晚期阶段。因此,建议在患有尺侧腕痛的患者中进行 DRUJ 的 US 检查。