Hutin Emilie, Pradon Didier, Barbier Franck, Gracies Jean-Michel, Bussel Bernard, Roche Nicolas
Laboratoire d'Analyse du Mouvement, CIC-IT 805, AP-HP, CHU Raymond Poincaré, Garches, France.
Clin Biomech (Bristol). 2011 Mar;26(3):304-11. doi: 10.1016/j.clinbiomech.2010.10.007. Epub 2010 Nov 12.
The mechanisms altering knee flexion in hemiparetic gait may be neurological (muscle overactivity) or orthopedic (soft tissue contracture) in nature, a distinction which is difficult to ascertain clinically during gait. This study aimed to distinguish the 2 mechanisms in evaluating thigh-shank coordination, which may show instability across the gait cycle in the case of bursting rectus femoris overactivity.
We measured thigh-shank coordination in the sagittal plane using the continuous relative phase during gait in 15 healthy subjects without and with an orthotic knee constraint (control and constrained) and 14 subjects with hemiparesis and rectus femoris overactivity before (pre) and after botulinum toxin injection.
Compared with the control group, both orthopedic and neurological knee flexion limitations were associated with decreased root-mean square of continuous relative phase over swing (control, 72.9; constrained, 26.0, P<0.001; pre, 31.3, P<0.001). However, only the neurological limitation was characterized by a higher number of continuous relative phase reversals over swing (control, 2.3; pre, 4.0; P=0.001) and late stance (control, 0.6; pre, 1.7; P<0.001). Botulinum toxin injection was associated with a 40% increase in root-mean square of continuous relative phase during swing and a 41% decrease in number of continuous relative phase reversals during late stance, while peak knee flexion was increased by 31%.
In hemiparesis, rectus femoris overactivity at swing phase is associated with alternating thigh-shank coordination in swing and late stance, which improves after botulinum toxin injection. Coordination analysis may help to distinguish neurological from orthopedic factors in knee flexion impairment.
偏瘫步态中膝关节屈曲改变的机制可能是神经性的(肌肉过度活跃)或骨科性的(软组织挛缩),在步态过程中临床上很难区分这两种机制。本研究旨在区分这两种机制,以评估大腿-小腿协调性,在股直肌过度活跃的情况下,这种协调性可能在整个步态周期中表现出不稳定。
我们在15名健康受试者(无矫形膝关节约束和有矫形膝关节约束,分别为对照组和约束组)以及14名股直肌过度活跃的偏瘫受试者肉毒杆菌毒素注射前后,通过步态期间的连续相对相位测量矢状面的大腿-小腿协调性。
与对照组相比,骨科性和神经性膝关节屈曲受限均与摆动期连续相对相位均方根降低有关(对照组,72.9;约束组,26.0,P<0.001;注射前,31.3,P<0.001)。然而,只有神经性受限的特征是摆动期连续相对相位反转次数更多(对照组,2.3;注射前,4.0;P=0.001)以及站立后期更多(对照组,0.6;注射前,1.7;P<0.001)。肉毒杆菌毒素注射与摆动期连续相对相位均方根增加40%以及站立后期连续相对相位反转次数减少41%相关,同时膝关节最大屈曲增加了31%。
在偏瘫中,摆动期股直肌过度活跃与摆动期和站立后期大腿-小腿协调性交替有关,肉毒杆菌毒素注射后这种协调性得到改善。协调性分析可能有助于区分膝关节屈曲障碍中的神经性因素和骨科性因素。