Kimme-Smith C, Bassett L W, Gold R H, Zheutlin J, Gornbein J A
Iris Cantor Center for Breast Imaging, UCLA School of Medicine 90024.
AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1990 Apr;154(4):713-9. doi: 10.2214/ajr.154.4.2107663.
Five types of film (Kodak OM, Kodak OM-SO177, Konica CM, Dupont Microvision, and Fuji MiMa) exposed in combination with seven different intensifying screens (Min R, Min R Medium, Siemens Orthox MA, Kyokka HR Mammo Fine, Agfa Gevaert Detail S (old and new), and Konica Monarch) were processed for either 90 sec (at 33.3 degrees C) or 3 min (at 35.0 degrees C). The films imaged a Computerized Imaging Reference System phantom with additional detail test objects placed on its surface to produce four groups of objects with which to evaluate resolution and contrast. For objects that tested resolution, the Kyokka HR Mammo Fine (Fuji) screen was statistically significantly superior; for objects that tested contrast, the Konica Monarch screen was statistically significantly superior. Extended processing did not affect Dupont and Kodak OM film as much as it affected the other films. It did affect contrast for the other films tested. The mean glandular doses from gridless exposures ranged from 32 to 80 mrad (0.32-0.80 mGy) over all film/screen/processing combinations for a 4.5-cm-thick test object. Several new film/screen combinations can provide images superior to the Kodak Min R/OM combination at a reduced radiation dose. The Kyokka HR Mammo Fine (Fuji) screen was found statistically superior in radiographic resolution of mammographic test objects and the Konica Monarch screen was found to be superior in defining contrast.
将五种类型的胶片(柯达OM、柯达OM - SO177、柯尼卡CM、杜邦显微视觉和富士MiMa)与七种不同的增感屏(敏R、敏R中速、西门子Orthox MA、协和HR乳腺精细型、爱克发吉华Detail S(新旧两种)和柯尼卡帝王型)组合曝光后,分别在90秒(33.3摄氏度)或3分钟(35.0摄氏度)下进行冲洗。这些胶片对计算机成像参考系统体模成像,体模表面放置了额外的细节测试物体,以产生四组物体用于评估分辨率和对比度。对于测试分辨率的物体,协和HR乳腺精细型(富士)增感屏在统计学上显著更优;对于测试对比度的物体,柯尼卡帝王型增感屏在统计学上显著更优。延长冲洗对杜邦和柯达OM胶片的影响不如对其他胶片的影响大。它确实影响了所测试的其他胶片的对比度。对于一个4.5厘米厚的测试物体,在所有胶片/增感屏/冲洗组合中,无网格曝光的平均腺体剂量范围为32至80毫拉德(0.32 - 0.80毫戈瑞)。几种新的胶片/增感屏组合可以在降低辐射剂量的情况下提供优于柯达敏R/OM组合的图像。研究发现,协和HR乳腺精细型(富士)增感屏在乳腺摄影测试物体的射线照相分辨率方面在统计学上更优,柯尼卡帝王型增感屏在定义对比度方面更优。