Pacific Graduate School ofPsychology, Palo Alto University, 1791 Arastradero Rd., Palo Alto, CA 94063, USA.
J Clin Psychol. 2011 Feb;67(2):133-42. doi: 10.1002/jclp.20753.
Psychotherapists from all professions and perspectives periodically struggle to effectively manage a patient's resistance to change. This article provides definitions and examples of patient-treatment matching applied to patient resistance or reactance. We report the results from an original meta-analysis of 12 select studies (N = 1,102) on matching therapist directiveness to patient reactance. Our findings support the hypothesis that patients exhibiting low levels of trait-like resistance respond better to directive types of treatment, while patients with high levels of resistance respond best to nondirective treatments (d = .82). Limitations of the research reviewed are noted, and practice recommendations are advanced.
来自不同专业和视角的心理治疗师都在周期性地努力,以有效地处理患者对改变的抵触。本文提供了患者治疗匹配的定义和示例,用于处理患者的抵触或反抗。我们报告了一项针对 12 项精选研究(N = 1,102)的原始元分析的结果,该研究涉及将治疗师的直接性与患者的反应性相匹配。我们的发现支持这样的假设,即表现出低水平特质性抵触的患者对指导性治疗反应更好,而具有高水平抵触的患者对非指导性治疗反应更好(d =.82)。本文还注意到了所审查研究的局限性,并提出了实践建议。