Miller Mia E, Moriarty John M, Blackwell Keith E, Finn J Paul, Yiee Jenny H, Nabili Vishad
David Geffen School of Medicine, University of California, Los Angeles, Building CHS 62-237, 10833 Le Conte Ave, Los Angeles, CA 90095, USA.
Arch Facial Plast Surg. 2011 Jan-Feb;13(1):36-40. doi: 10.1001/archfacial.2010.110.
To investigate whether preoperative magnetic resonance angiography (MRA) is predictive of surgical findings in fibula free flap surgery for head and neck reconstruction.
Retrospective review (April 2004 until September 2009) of 123 patients who underwent preoperative MRA as part of surgical planning for fibula free flap tissue transfer for head and neck reconstruction. Each MRA was reviewed by a board-certified radiologist masked to the intraoperative findings and to the number of septocutaneous perforators documented. Operative notes were reviewed and the number of septocutaneous perforators found during the operation was recorded. A κ interrater agreement statistic was calculated to compare these values.
Two vascular anomalies found during the operation were undetected by MRA. Analysis of the entire cohort demonstrated that agreement between the number of perforators documented on MRA and the number found intraoperatively approached zero (unweighted κ = -0.088, P = .04). The agreement between the 2 values was 17.9% and the average percentage correctly classified was 10.9%.
Contrary to previous reports, preoperative MRA does not accurately predict the presence and/or number of skin perforators found intraoperatively for a fibula free flap operation. The surgeon should not be dissuaded from planning a fibula free flap operation if skin perforators appear unfavorable on preoperative MRA because intraoperative observation is definitive. The surgeon should prepare for anomalous cases in which perforators may arise from the posterior tibial system. Further investigation is needed to achieve more accurate imaging modalities for evaluating septocutaneous perforators prior to free fibula flap transfer.
探讨术前磁共振血管造影(MRA)能否预测用于头颈部重建的游离腓骨瓣手术中的手术发现。
回顾性分析2004年4月至2009年9月期间123例行术前MRA检查的患者,这些检查作为头颈部重建游离腓骨瓣组织移植手术规划的一部分。每位MRA检查结果由一名认证放射科医生评估,该医生对术中发现及记录的穿支皮动脉数量不知情。查阅手术记录并记录手术中发现的穿支皮动脉数量。计算κ检验一致性统计量以比较这些数值。
手术中发现的2处血管异常在MRA检查中未被检测到。对整个队列的分析表明,MRA记录的穿支数量与术中发现的数量之间的一致性接近零(非加权κ=-0.088,P=0.04)。这两个数值之间的一致性为17.9%,正确分类的平均百分比为10.9%。
与先前的报道相反,术前MRA不能准确预测游离腓骨瓣手术中术中发现的皮肤穿支的存在和/或数量。如果术前MRA显示皮肤穿支情况不佳,外科医生不应因此放弃游离腓骨瓣手术的规划,因为术中观察才是决定性的。外科医生应做好准备应对穿支可能来自胫后系统的异常情况。需要进一步研究以获得更准确的成像方式,用于在游离腓骨瓣移植术前评估穿支皮动脉。