Mishra Sandeep, Logue David M, Abiola Ife O, Cade William H
Department of Psychology, University of Lethbridge, Lethbridge, Canada.
J Comp Psychol. 2011 Feb;125(1):40-7. doi: 10.1037/a0020656.
Consistent individual differences in the tendency to accept risk have been demonstrated in invertebrates, fish, birds, and mammals, including humans. These individual differences have been associated with size, growth rate, survival, and reproductive success. Little research, however, has investigated the effect of developmental environment on individual differences in risk-acceptance. Competing hypotheses offer different explanations of how variation in the quality of the developmental environment affects risk-acceptance in adults. The first hypothesis states that individuals developing in poor quality environments take risks because such behavior is their only means of obtaining adequate fitness returns. The second hypothesis states that individuals developing in poor environments avoid risk because their poor physical condition makes them especially vulnerable to injury or death. We measured several forms of risk-accepting behavior (exploration, foraging, and recovery after disturbance) in male hissing cockroaches (Gromphadorhina portentosa) that had developed in nutritional and social environments of varying quality. Individuals raised on poor nutrition diets exhibited lower levels of risk-acceptance than those raised on high nutrition diets. Risk-acceptance among individuals that developed on poor nutrition diets was negatively correlated with body size. We conclude that quality of developmental environment affects risk-acceptance across behavioral contexts in male hissing cockroaches. Our findings are consistent with the hypothesis that condition-dependent vulnerability mediates the relationship between developmental environment and risk-acceptance.
包括人类在内的无脊椎动物、鱼类、鸟类和哺乳动物中,都已证实存在接受风险倾向方面持续的个体差异。这些个体差异与体型大小、生长速率、生存及繁殖成功率有关。然而,鲜有研究探讨发育环境对风险接受度个体差异的影响。相互竞争的假说对发育环境质量的变化如何影响成年个体的风险接受度给出了不同解释。第一个假说认为,在质量较差的环境中发育的个体冒险是因为这种行为是他们获得足够适合度回报的唯一途径。第二个假说认为,在较差环境中发育的个体规避风险是因为他们较差的身体状况使他们特别容易受伤或死亡。我们对在不同质量的营养和社会环境中发育的雄性马达加斯加发声蟑螂(马岛发声蜚蠊)的几种风险接受行为形式(探索、觅食及受干扰后的恢复)进行了测量。在营养较差的饮食条件下饲养的个体比在高营养饮食条件下饲养的个体表现出更低的风险接受水平。在营养较差的饮食条件下发育的个体的风险接受度与体型大小呈负相关。我们得出结论,发育环境质量会影响雄性马达加斯加发声蟑螂在各种行为情境下的风险接受度。我们的研究结果与以下假说一致,即依赖于条件的脆弱性介导了发育环境与风险接受度之间的关系。