Department of Neurology, University of Michigan Health Systems, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, USA.
Emerg Med J. 2012 Jan;29(1):43-6. doi: 10.1136/emj.2010.104844. Epub 2011 Jan 18.
A principal reason to order a head CT scan for dizziness patients is to exclude stroke. As CT imaging is substantially limited in assessing for any acute lesions other than haemorrhage, the most important stroke syndrome adequately evaluated by CT is intracerebral haemorrhage (ICH). A population based stroke database was used to assess the frequency with which ICH might mimic a benign dizziness presentation.
The Brain Attack Surveillance in Corpus Christi project was used to identify cases of ICH from 1 January 2000 to 26 December 2007. The hospital records of ICH cases with a National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale of <2 were abstracted for more detailed information. Cases were classified as benign dizziness presentations when isolated dizziness and a normal general neurological examination were documented.
Of 595 ICH cases, only 2.2% (13 of 595) had dizziness as the primary presenting symptom and a National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale of <2. No case mimicked a benign dizziness presentation. Only one case had isolated dizziness symptoms but this patient had dysmetria documented on the examination. All other cases had either focal or global neurological symptoms or examination abnormalities.
This study provides further support for the notion that ICH is highly unlikely to mimic a benign dizziness presentation. Coupled with the limitations of CT to show acute ischaemia in the posterior fossa, these results suggest that screening for ICH may not be necessary in benign appearing dizziness presentations although more research is needed.
头晕患者进行头部 CT 扫描的主要原因是排除中风。由于 CT 成像在评估除出血以外的任何急性病变方面存在很大局限性,因此 CT 充分评估的最重要中风综合征是脑内出血(ICH)。本研究使用基于人群的中风数据库来评估 ICH 可能模拟良性头晕表现的频率。
利用 Corpus Christi 脑部疾病监测项目来识别 2000 年 1 月 1 日至 2007 年 12 月 26 日的 ICH 病例。对 NIHSS 评分<2 的 ICH 病例的医院记录进行摘录,以获取更详细的信息。当孤立性头晕和正常的一般神经系统检查记录在案时,将病例分类为良性头晕表现。
在 595 例 ICH 病例中,仅有 2.2%(13/595)为首发症状为头晕且 NIHSS 评分<2。没有病例模拟良性头晕表现。仅有 1 例病例仅有孤立性头晕症状,但该患者在检查中出现了共济失调。所有其他病例均存在局灶性或全身性神经症状或检查异常。
本研究进一步证实了 ICH 极不可能模拟良性头晕表现的观点。结合 CT 在显示后颅窝急性缺血方面的局限性,这些结果表明,在良性头晕表现中可能不需要筛查 ICH,但需要更多的研究。