Forensic Psychiatric Services Commission, 70 Colony Farm Rd., Port Coquitlam, British Columbia V3C 5X9, Canada.
Psychiatr Serv. 2011 Feb;62(2):200-5. doi: 10.1176/ps.62.2.pss6202_0200.
Deinstitutionalization is an ongoing process, as many jurisdictions continue to struggle with redesigning their psychiatric systems. Historically, reducing psychiatric beds and closing hospitals have resulted in deleterious outcomes for people with severe and persistent mental illness. More recent evidence suggests that careful implementation of deinstitutionalization policies can thwart potential adverse consequences and may even foster favorable outcomes. This study evaluated the extent to which the recent devolution of the only tertiary psychiatric hospital in British Columbia resulted in a direct shift of individuals to other institutional sectors, such as criminal justice and health sectors.
Admission rates to general hospitals, continuing care facilities, correctional institutions, and forensic psychiatric facilities were compared among two patient groups: those discharged before the realignment of the tertiary psychiatric hospital system (prerealignment cohort) (N=164) and those discharged after initiation of the system reforms (postrealignment cohort) (N=171).
Most of the patients in the postrealignment cohort have remained in the tertiary care settings to which they were originally discharged. For patients in the postrealignment cohort, contact with other institutional sectors was rare and shorter in duration than it was for patients in the prerealignment cohort.
This study provides preliminary evidence that recent efforts to realign British Columbia's provincial tertiary psychiatric hospital system have not resulted in a significant shift of the relocated patients to institutions in other sectors.
去机构化是一个持续的过程,因为许多司法管辖区仍在努力重新设计他们的精神科系统。从历史上看,减少精神科床位和关闭医院导致严重和持久的精神疾病患者产生有害后果。最近的证据表明,仔细实施去机构化政策可以阻止潜在的不利后果,甚至可能促进有利的结果。本研究评估了不列颠哥伦比亚省唯一的三级精神病医院最近的权力下放在多大程度上直接导致个人转移到其他机构部门,如刑事司法和卫生部门。
比较了两组患者的普通医院、长期护理机构、惩教机构和法医精神病学机构的入院率:在三级精神病医院系统重新调整之前出院的患者(预调整队列)(N=164)和在系统改革启动后出院的患者(后调整队列)(N=171)。
后调整队列中的大多数患者仍留在他们最初出院的三级护理环境中。对于后调整队列的患者,与其他机构部门的接触很少,持续时间也比预调整队列的患者短。
本研究初步证明,不列颠哥伦比亚省最近努力重新调整省级三级精神病医院系统的努力并没有导致被重新安置的患者大量转移到其他部门的机构。