Slagter Heleen A, Davidson Richard J, Lutz Antoine
Brain and Cognition Unit, Department of Psychology, University of Amsterdam Amsterdam, Netherlands.
Front Hum Neurosci. 2011 Feb 10;5:17. doi: 10.3389/fnhum.2011.00017. eCollection 2011.
Although the adult brain was once seen as a rather static organ, it is now clear that the organization of brain circuitry is constantly changing as a function of experience or learning. Yet, research also shows that learning is often specific to the trained stimuli and task, and does not improve performance on novel tasks, even very similar ones. This perspective examines the idea that systematic mental training, as cultivated by meditation, can induce learning that is not stimulus or task specific, but process specific. Many meditation practices are explicitly designed to enhance specific, well-defined core cognitive processes. We will argue that this focus on enhancing core cognitive processes, as well as several general characteristics of meditation regimens, may specifically foster process-specific learning. To this end, we first define meditation and discuss key findings from recent neuroimaging studies of meditation. We then identify several characteristics of specific meditation training regimes that may determine process-specific learning. These characteristics include ongoing variability in stimulus input, the meta-cognitive nature of the processes trained, task difficulty, the focus on maintaining an optimal level of arousal, and the duration of training. Lastly, we discuss the methodological challenges that researchers face when attempting to control or characterize the multiple factors that may underlie meditation training effects.
尽管成人大脑曾被视为一个相当静态的器官,但现在很明显,大脑神经回路的组织会随着经验或学习而不断变化。然而,研究也表明,学习往往特定于所训练的刺激和任务,即使是非常相似的新任务,学习也不会提高其表现。本文探讨了这样一种观点,即作为冥想所培养的系统性心理训练,可以诱导出并非特定于刺激或任务,而是特定于过程的学习。许多冥想练习都明确旨在增强特定的、定义明确的核心认知过程。我们将论证,这种对增强核心认知过程的关注,以及冥想训练方案的几个一般特征,可能会特别促进特定于过程的学习。为此,我们首先定义冥想,并讨论近期冥想神经影像学研究的关键发现。然后,我们确定特定冥想训练方案的几个特征,这些特征可能决定特定于过程的学习。这些特征包括刺激输入的持续变化、所训练过程的元认知性质、任务难度、对维持最佳唤醒水平的关注以及训练持续时间。最后,我们讨论研究人员在试图控制或描述可能构成冥想训练效果基础的多个因素时所面临的方法学挑战。