Department of Neurological Surgery, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA.
Neurosurgery. 2011 Sep;69(3):605-13; discussion 613-4. doi: 10.1227/NEU.0b013e31821a42f3.
Deterioration in hearing after Gamma Knife radiosurgery of vestibular schwannomas is a well-documented risk. Recent studies suggest a correlation between cochlear radiation dose and hearing preservation.
This study identifies additional variables that predict hearing loss after radiosurgery.
Retrospective analysis of 53 patients with audiogram follow-up. Median marginal tumor dose was 12.5 Gy. Mean tumor volume was 1.11 cm. Statistical analysis included multivariate stepwise backward linear regression and multivariate logistic regression. Variables included age, prescription dose, tumor volume, intracanalicular length, and maximum and mean cochlear dose. Dose volume histograms were generated. The percentage of the cochlear volume that received 3.6 Gy or greater, 4.7 Gy or greater, and 5.3 Gy or greater was calculated. Plan conformality indicators were calculated.
Forty-two patients had a less than 20-dB change in their pure tone average, with a hearing preservation rate of 79%. Two statistically significant predictors of hearing loss were identified using multivariate analysis: tumor coverage (odds ratio: 1.38 × 10) and age (odds ratio: 1.1 per year). Multivariate linear regression was used to predict change in pure tone average. Age and percentage of the cochlear volume receiving 5.3 Gy or greater were found to be statistically significant predictor variables.
Older patients are more vulnerable to detrimental effects of Gamma Knife radiosurgery on hearing. We propose that cochlear dose volume histograms be created and used to reduce the percentage of the cochlear volume exposed to radiation doses greater than 5.3 Gy. This is the first report to suggest that the conformity index tumor coverage may be an important predictor of hearing outcomes.
伽玛刀放射外科治疗前庭神经鞘瘤后听力下降是一个有据可查的风险。最近的研究表明,耳蜗剂量与听力保护之间存在相关性。
本研究旨在确定预测放射外科治疗后听力损失的其他变量。
回顾性分析 53 例听力随访患者。中位边缘肿瘤剂量为 12.5Gy。平均肿瘤体积为 1.11cm³。统计分析包括多元逐步向后线性回归和多元逻辑回归。变量包括年龄、处方剂量、肿瘤体积、内管长度以及最大和平均耳蜗剂量。生成剂量体积直方图。计算接受 3.6Gy 或更大、4.7Gy 或更大和 5.3Gy 或更大的耳蜗体积百分比。计算计划适形性指标。
42 例患者纯音平均听阈变化小于 20dB,听力保留率为 79%。使用多元分析确定了两个听力损失的统计学显著预测因子:肿瘤覆盖(优势比:1.38×10)和年龄(优势比:每年增加 1.1)。使用多元线性回归预测纯音平均听阈的变化。发现年龄和接受 5.3Gy 或更大剂量的耳蜗体积百分比是统计学上显著的预测变量。
年龄较大的患者更容易受到伽玛刀放射外科治疗对听力的不利影响。我们建议创建耳蜗剂量体积直方图,并使用该图来降低接受大于 5.3Gy 辐射剂量的耳蜗体积百分比。这是第一个表明肿瘤覆盖适形指数可能是听力结果的重要预测因子的报告。