Jarrell Brett, Davis Stephen M, Coyner John, Crocco Todd, Whiteman Charles
West Virginia University, USA.
W V Med J. 2011 Mar-Apr;107(2):24, 26-8.
One previous study found that healthlines affiliated with academic neurology programs recommended non-emergent treatment for a hypothetical stroke scenario almost one quarter of the time, which could contribute to patients presenting too late for time dependent stroke therapies. We assessed the treatment advice given in a hypothetical stroke scenario by primary care physician offices across the United States.
We obtained a national listing of United States primary care physician offices from Yellowpages.com, and selected a systematic random sample of numbers to call. The respondent answering the phone was presented with a standardized, scripted stroke patient scenario, and asked to choose one of four responses that could be provided (wait for symptom resolution, attempt to schedule an office appointment later in the day, schedule an office visit within two days, call 911 for ambulance transport to a hospital).
Forty-two respondents completed the survey (average age = 43 years; 88% female), with 29% (95% CI 17%-44%) recommending scheduling an appointment later in the day if symptoms do not resolve. The remaining respondents recommended calling 911. When presented with a heart attack scenario, 100% of respondents recommended calling 911.
Almost one third of the primary care physician offices recommended scheduling an appointment later in the day for a hypothetical stroke case, despite always giving the correct answer of call 911 for a classic heart attack scenario. These results suggest that stroke education with specific emphasis on the need to call 911 may be needed for primary care physician office receptionists.
先前的一项研究发现,与学术性神经学项目相关的健康热线在近四分之一的假设性中风病例中推荐了非紧急治疗,这可能导致患者因依赖时间的中风治疗就诊过晚。我们评估了美国各地初级保健医生办公室针对假设性中风病例给出的治疗建议。
我们从Yellowpages.com获取了美国初级保健医生办公室的全国名录,并通过系统随机抽样选择号码进行拨打。接听电话的受访者会看到一个标准化的、照本宣科的中风患者病例,并被要求从可能提供的四种回复中选择一种(等待症状缓解、尝试安排当天晚些时候的门诊预约、在两天内安排门诊就诊、拨打911呼叫救护车送往医院)。
42名受访者完成了调查(平均年龄 = 43岁;88%为女性),29%(95%置信区间17% - 44%)建议如果症状未缓解则安排当天晚些时候的预约。其余受访者建议拨打911。当面对心脏病发作病例时,100%的受访者建议拨打911。
尽管在典型心脏病发作病例中总是给出拨打911的正确答案,但近三分之一的初级保健医生办公室建议在假设性中风病例中安排当天晚些时候的预约。这些结果表明,可能需要对初级保健医生办公室的接待员进行中风教育,特别强调拨打911的必要性。