Kalil Ariel, Wightman Patrick
University of Chicago.
Soc Sci Q. 2011;92(1):57-78. doi: 10.1111/j.1540-6237.2011.00757.x.
Objectives. We aim to understand why blacks are significantly less likely than whites to perpetuate their middle-class status across generations. To do so, we focus on the potentially different associations between parental job loss and youth's educational attainment in black and white middle-class families.Methods. We use data from the Panel Study of Income Dynamics (PSID), following those children “born” into the survey between 1968 and 1979 and followed through age 21. We conduct multivariate regression analyses to test the association between parental job loss during childhood and youth's educational attainment by age 21.Results. We find that parental job loss is associated with a lesser likelihood of obtaining any postsecondary education for all offspring, but that the association for blacks is almost three times as strong. A substantial share of the differential impact of job loss on black and white middle-class youth is explained by race differences in household wealth, long-run measures of family income, and, especially, parental experience of long-term unemployment.Conclusions. These findings highlight the fragile economic foundation of the black middle class and suggest that intergenerational persistence of class status in this population may be highly dependent on the avoidance of common economic shocks.
目标。我们旨在了解为何黑人在代际间维持中产阶级地位的可能性显著低于白人。为此,我们聚焦于黑人与白人中产阶级家庭中父母失业与子女教育成就之间可能存在的不同关联。
方法。我们使用收入动态面板研究(PSID)的数据,追踪那些在1968年至1979年期间“出生”于该调查且一直追踪到21岁的儿童。我们进行多元回归分析,以检验童年时期父母失业与子女到21岁时的教育成就之间的关联。
结果。我们发现,父母失业与所有子女获得任何高等教育的可能性降低有关,但这种关联对黑人的影响几乎是白人的三倍。家庭财富的种族差异、家庭收入的长期衡量指标,尤其是父母长期失业的经历,解释了失业对黑人和白人中产阶级青年的差异影响中的很大一部分。
结论。这些发现凸显了黑人中产阶级脆弱的经济基础,并表明该群体中阶级地位的代际延续可能高度依赖于避免常见的经济冲击。