Korea National Sport University, Sports Science Institute, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
Int J Sports Med. 2011 Aug;32(8):580-5. doi: 10.1055/s-0031-1277179. Epub 2011 May 11.
The purpose of this study was to evaluate equations of Leger (E1, 1988) and Brewer (E2, 1988) to predict VO (2max) in Korean adults (158 men and 155 women), and reliability tests were randomly conducted among men ( N=90) and women (n=29) in addition to VO (2max) measurements during a graded exercise treadmill test. Both equations significantly underestimated VO (2max) compared to those from the treadmill test ( P<0.01). A strong intra-class correlation between the treadmill result and 20 m shuttle run test was detected (0.86-0.94, P<0.001). 95 percentile limit of agreement of absolute difference in E1 and E2 in both genders were mostly larger than results from the treadmill test. There was a strong correlation between laboratory test and retest but testing hypothesis of equality of means in men showed significant bias ( P=0.003), except difference between test and retest in women ( P=0.05). The test and retest of the upper and lower of absolute difference ± 95% limit of agreement were -4.86 to -19.05 (men) and 13.61 to 27.91 (women). In conclusion, their equations, based on the results, should not be applied for predicting VO (2max) in Korean adults.
本研究旨在评估 Leger(E1,1988 年)和 Brewer(E2,1988 年)方程在预测韩国成年人(男性 158 人,女性 155 人)最大摄氧量(VO2max)的准确性,并对男性(N=90)和女性(n=29)进行了随机可靠性测试,除了在跑步机测试中测量 VO2max 之外。与跑步机测试相比,这两种方程均明显低估了 VO2max(P<0.01)。在跑步机测试结果与 20 米穿梭跑测试之间检测到很强的组内相关性(0.86-0.94,P<0.001)。两种性别中 E1 和 E2 的绝对差异的 95%一致性界限的上限大多大于跑步机测试的结果。实验室测试与复测之间存在很强的相关性,但在男性中,均值相等的测试假设显示出显著的偏差(P=0.003),除了女性中测试和复测之间的差异(P=0.05)。绝对差异±95%一致性界限上下限的测试和复测值为-4.86 至-19.05(男性)和 13.61 至 27.91(女性)。总之,根据研究结果,这些方程不应用于预测韩国成年人的 VO2max。