Signorelli Monique E, Madill Catherine J, McCabe Patricia
Discipline of Speech Pathology, Faculty of Health Sciences, The University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia.
Int J Speech Lang Pathol. 2011 Jun;13(3):227-38. doi: 10.3109/17549507.2011.549570.
The purpose of this study was to determine the management options and voice therapy techniques currently being used by practicing speech-language pathologists (SLPs) to treat vocal fold nodules (VFNs) in children. The sources used by SLPs to inform and guide their clinical decisions when managing VFNs in children were also explored. Sixty-two SLPs completed a 23-item web-based survey. Data was analysed using frequency counts, content analyses, and supplementary analyses. SLPs reported using a range of management options and voice therapy techniques to treat VFNs in children. Voice therapy was reportedly the most frequently used management option across all respondents, with the majority of SLPs using a combination of indirect and direct voice therapy techniques. When selecting voice therapy techniques, the majority of SLPs reported that they did not use the limited external evidence available to guide their clinical decisions. Additionally, the majority of SLPs reported that they frequently relied on lower levels of evidence or non-evidence-based sources to guide clinical practice both in the presence and absence of higher quality evidence. Further research needs to investigate strategies to remove the barriers that impede SLPs use of external evidence when managing VFNs in children.
本研究的目的是确定执业言语语言病理学家(SLP)目前用于治疗儿童声带小结(VFN)的管理方案和嗓音治疗技术。同时还探讨了SLP在管理儿童VFN时用于指导其临床决策的信息来源。62名SLP完成了一项包含23个项目的网络调查。使用频数计数、内容分析和补充分析对数据进行了分析。SLP报告称使用了一系列管理方案和嗓音治疗技术来治疗儿童VFN。据报道,嗓音治疗是所有受访者中最常用的管理方案,大多数SLP使用间接和直接嗓音治疗技术相结合的方法。在选择嗓音治疗技术时,大多数SLP报告称他们没有使用有限的外部证据来指导临床决策。此外,大多数SLP报告称,无论是否有更高质量的证据,他们在临床实践中经常依赖较低水平的证据或非循证来源。需要进一步研究以调查消除阻碍SLP在管理儿童VFN时使用外部证据的障碍的策略。