Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2011 Jun;20(6):311-9. doi: 10.1007/s00787-011-0176-2. Epub 2011 May 14.
This study examined substance use rates and related background factors among adolescents in special education (SE) and in residential youth care institutions (RYC). Information on substance use from 531 adolescents in RYC, 603 adolescents in SE for students with behavioral problems (SEB) and 1,905 adolescents in SE for students with learning disabilities (SEL) was compared with information from 7,041 adolescents who attended mainstream education. Results show that substance use rates are particularly high among adolescents in RYC and in SEB. For example, 22% of the 12-13 years old in RYC and 16% in SEB was a daily smoker compared with 1% of their counterparts in mainstream education. Background factors, including age, ethnic background and family situation, partly explained the differences in substance use between mainstream education on the one hand and SE and RYC on the other hand, but differences between the groups remained substantial and significant. Several interaction effects were found in the relation between SE/RYC and substance use that were all in line with the risk paradox: some subgroups that are normally at lower risk for problem behavior are at higher risk when they are subjected to high-risk indicators. The elevated risk of substance use among adolescents in RYC/SE was in some cases particularly marked for those who would normally be at lower risk for substance use (girls in SEB for heavy alcohol drinking and cannabis use, ethnic minority adolescents and adolescents with a stable family situation in RYC for respectively heavy weekly alcohol drinking and daily use of tobacco). Results of this study have important implications for health education and intervention programs for adolescents in RYC and SE.
本研究考察了特殊教育(SE)和住宿青年关爱机构(RYC)中青少年的物质使用率及相关背景因素。研究比较了 RYC 中 531 名青少年、SE 中行为问题学生(SEB)组 603 名青少年和 SE 中学习障碍学生(SEL)组 1905 名青少年与主流教育组 7041 名青少年的物质使用信息。结果表明,RYC 和 SEB 中的青少年物质使用率特别高。例如,12-13 岁的 RYC 青少年中,有 22%是每天吸烟的,而 SEB 青少年中这一比例为 16%,相比之下,主流教育组的这一比例为 1%。背景因素,包括年龄、种族背景和家庭状况,部分解释了主流教育与 SE 和 RYC 之间物质使用的差异,但组间差异仍然很大且显著。在 SE/RYC 与物质使用之间的关系中发现了几个交互效应,这些效应都符合风险悖论:一些通常处于较低问题行为风险的亚组,在面临高风险指标时,风险更高。RYC/SE 中的青少年物质使用风险升高,在某些情况下,对于那些通常物质使用风险较低的青少年(SEB 中的女孩重度饮酒和吸食大麻、RYC 中的少数民族青少年和家庭状况稳定的青少年分别是重度每周饮酒和每日吸烟)来说尤为明显。本研究结果对 RYC 和 SE 中青少年的健康教育和干预计划具有重要意义。