Department of Environmental Health Science and Georgia Genomics Facility, Environmental Health Science Building, University of Georgia, Athens, GA 30602, USA.
Mol Ecol Resour. 2011 Sep;11(5):759-69. doi: 10.1111/j.1755-0998.2011.03024.x. Epub 2011 May 19.
The diversity of available 2(nd) and 3(rd) generation DNA sequencing platforms is increasing rapidly. Costs for these systems range from < $100,000 to more than $1,000,000, with instrument run times ranging from minutes to weeks. Extensive trade-offs exist among these platforms. I summarize the major characteristics of each commercially available platform to enable direct comparisons. In terms of cost per megabase (Mb) of sequence, the Illumina and SOLiD platforms are clearly superior (≤ $0.10/Mb vs. > $10/Mb for 454 and some Ion Torrent chips). In terms of cost per nonmultiplexed sample and instrument run time, the Pacific Biosciences and Ion Torrent platforms excel, with the 454 GS Junior and Illumina MiSeq also notable in this regard. All platforms allow multiplexing of samples, but details of library preparation, experimental design and data analysis can constrain the options. The wide range of characteristics among available platforms provides opportunities both to conduct groundbreaking studies and to waste money on scales that were previously infeasible. Thus, careful thought about the desired characteristics of these systems is warranted before purchasing or using any of them. Updated information from this guide will be maintained at: http://dna.uga.edu/ and http://tomato.biol.trinity.edu/blog/.
现有的第二代和第三代 DNA 测序平台的多样性正在迅速增加。这些系统的成本从低于 10 万美元到超过 100 万美元不等,仪器运行时间从几分钟到几周不等。这些平台之间存在着广泛的权衡。我总结了每个商业上可用的平台的主要特点,以便进行直接比较。就每兆碱基(Mb)的测序成本而言,Illumina 和 SOLiD 平台显然具有优势(≤0.10 美元/Mb 比 454 和一些 Ion Torrent 芯片的 > 10 美元/Mb)。就每个非多重样本和仪器运行时间的成本而言,Pacific Biosciences 和 Ion Torrent 平台表现出色,454 GS Junior 和 Illumina MiSeq 也在此方面表现突出。所有平台都允许对样本进行多重化,但文库制备、实验设计和数据分析的细节可能会限制这些选项。现有的各种平台之间的广泛特征为开展开创性的研究提供了机会,也为以前不可行的规模浪费了资金。因此,在购买或使用任何一种平台之前,都应该仔细考虑这些系统所需的特点。本指南的最新信息将在以下网址维护:http://dna.uga.edu/ 和 http://tomato.biol.trinity.edu/blog/。