Wei Li, Sun Jun-Ying, Wang Yong, Yang Xing
First People's Hospital of Yibin, Yibin, China.
Orthopedics. 2011 May 18;34(5):348. doi: 10.3928/01477447-20110317-30.
Combined ipsilateral acetabular and femoral neck fractures are the result of high-energy trauma. Satisfactory treatment for this injury pattern remains a challenge, since traditional open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) is always accompanied by a high prevalence of posttraumatic arthritis and avascular necrosis of the femoral head. Eight of 502 acetabular fractures from 1990 to 2008 were diagnosed with combined ipsilateral femoral neck fracture, in which 5 patients' fractures were associated with hip dislocation. These patients were injured from falls, traffic accidents, or crushing accidents. Radiographs and computed tomography scans were taken to check acetabular and femoral neck fractures. All of the patients underwent surgery using appropriate approaches and techniques. Postoperative radiographs demonstrated anatomic or satisfactory reduction for acetabular fractures as well as excellent or good reduction for femoral neck fractures in all of the patients. Follow-up radiographs showed femoral head necrosis in the 5 patients with femoral head dislocations, but not in the other 3 patients. We have seen few patients with this injury pattern, which makes us unable to detect significant differences between the patients associated with femoral head dislocation and those without femoral head dislocation. But by considering the results of our study and those reported in the literature, we believe that for patients with ipsilateral acetabular and femoral neck fractures without hip dislocation, satisfactory results could be expected after ORIF. But for those cases associated with hip dislocation, alternative methods such as acute THR as primary treatment are worthy of consideration.
同侧髋臼和股骨颈联合骨折是高能创伤的结果。对于这种损伤模式,令人满意的治疗仍然是一项挑战,因为传统的切开复位内固定术(ORIF)总是伴随着创伤后关节炎和股骨头缺血性坏死的高发生率。在1990年至2008年的502例髋臼骨折中,有8例被诊断为同侧股骨颈联合骨折,其中5例骨折伴有髋关节脱位。这些患者因跌倒、交通事故或挤压事故受伤。拍摄X线片和计算机断层扫描以检查髋臼和股骨颈骨折。所有患者均采用适当的入路和技术进行手术。术后X线片显示所有患者的髋臼骨折均达到解剖复位或满意复位,股骨颈骨折达到良好或优秀复位。随访X线片显示,5例股骨头脱位患者出现股骨头坏死,而其他3例患者未出现。我们见过这种损伤模式的患者很少,这使得我们无法检测出伴有股骨头脱位的患者与不伴有股骨头脱位的患者之间的显著差异。但是,通过考虑我们的研究结果和文献报道的结果,我们认为对于同侧髋臼和股骨颈骨折且无髋关节脱位的患者,切开复位内固定术后有望获得满意的结果。但对于那些伴有髋关节脱位的病例,诸如一期急性全髋关节置换术等替代方法值得考虑。