Torrey E F
Health Research Group, Public Citizen, Inc., Washington, D.C. 20036.
Hosp Community Psychiatry. 1990 May;41(5):526-31. doi: 10.1176/ps.41.5.526.
Although deinstitutionalization has been linked with an increase in the number of mentally ill people who are homeless or in jails, several demonstration programs started during the past 30 years have shown that community-based services for the seriously mentally ill can be both humane and cost-effective. Four such programs, none of which has been widely implemented or has significantly influenced service delivery systems, are described. The author contends that the chaotic and illogical funding system for mental health services is primarily responsible for failure of the widespread implementation of demonstrably effective programs. The economic disincentives of the present system include lack of coordination of services at the state and local level and federal policies that favor hospitalization, restrict payment for outpatient and rehabilitation services, and discourage mentally ill persons from working. The author suggests that public services for the mentally ill are unlikely to improve significantly until such disincentives are addressed.
尽管去机构化与无家可归或入狱的精神病患者人数增加有关,但在过去30年里启动的几个示范项目表明,为严重精神病患者提供的社区服务既人道又具有成本效益。本文描述了四个这样的项目,这些项目均未得到广泛实施,也未对服务提供系统产生重大影响。作者认为,精神卫生服务混乱且不合逻辑的资金系统是明显有效的项目未能广泛实施的主要原因。当前系统的经济抑制因素包括州和地方层面服务缺乏协调,以及联邦政策倾向于住院治疗、限制门诊和康复服务支付,并阻碍精神病患者工作。作者建议,在解决这些抑制因素之前,为精神病患者提供的公共服务不太可能显著改善。