Neurophysiology Department, National Institute of Neurology, Mexico City, Mexico.
Seizure. 2011 Sep;20(7):564-9. doi: 10.1016/j.seizure.2011.04.006. Epub 2011 May 26.
Intraoperative electrocorticography (ECoG) has been in clinical use for many decades, yet the validity of this procedure in guiding resective surgery for temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) is still uncertain, especially in tailored temporal lobectomies in cases of TLE with hippocampal sclerosis.
Using a case-control design combined with descriptive and comparative analyses we retrospectively evaluated two groups of patients: patients (n=20) who had tailored temporal lobectomies guided by intraoperative ECoG and patients (n=19) who had standard temporal lobectomies without ECoG. Clinical and neuroimaging data, pre- and post-resection ECoG recordings, and seizure-free outcomes were reviewed.
Of the 20 patients who underwent epilepsy surgery guided by ECoG, pre-resection ECoG studies found spikes both in mesial temporal lobe (MTL) and lateral temporal lobe (LTL) in 10 patients, and restricted to the LTL or MTL in 7 and 3 patients respectively. Postsurgical ECoG captured residual epileptiform activity in only 3 patients, all of whom had MTL and LTL spikes prior to surgery. Postsurgical follow-up at 16.3 (±6.7) months found 15 (75%) patients were seizure free (1A), while 5 (25%) had other outcomes. Analysis found no difference in the proportion of seizure-free outcomes between patients with residual epileptiform activity compared to those without residual epileptiform activity, or between patients who had a tailored resection guided by ECoG and patients who had standard resections without ECoG monitoring.
The patients who underwent tailored temporal lobe epilepsy surgery guided by ECoG had similar outcome compared with the patients with epilepsy surgery not guided by ECoG.
术中皮层脑电图(ECoG)已在临床应用数十年,但在指导颞叶癫痫(TLE)切除术方面的有效性仍不确定,尤其是在伴有海马硬化的 TLE 患者进行个体化颞叶切除术时。
采用病例对照设计,结合描述性和对比分析,我们回顾性评估了两组患者:一组(n=20)患者接受了术中 ECoG 指导的个体化颞叶切除术,另一组(n=19)患者接受了标准的颞叶切除术,没有 ECoG。回顾了临床和神经影像学数据、术前和术后 ECoG 记录以及无癫痫发作的结果。
在 20 例接受 ECoG 指导的癫痫手术患者中,术前 ECoG 研究发现 10 例患者的内侧颞叶(MTL)和外侧颞叶(LTL)均有棘波,7 例和 3 例患者分别局限于 LTL 或 MTL。术后 ECoG 仅在 3 例患者中捕获到残留癫痫样活动,这 3 例患者术前均有 MTL 和 LTL 棘波。术后随访 16.3(±6.7)个月发现 15 例(75%)患者无癫痫发作(1A),5 例(25%)患者有其他结果。分析发现,有残留癫痫样活动的患者与无残留癫痫样活动的患者之间,或接受 ECoG 指导的个体化切除术的患者与未接受 ECoG 监测的标准切除术的患者之间,无癫痫发作的结果比例无差异。
接受 ECoG 指导的个体化颞叶癫痫手术的患者与未接受 ECoG 指导的癫痫手术患者的结果相似。