Hospital General de México O.P.D., Mexico.
J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol. 2012 May;26(5):611-8. doi: 10.1111/j.1468-3083.2011.04135.x. Epub 2011 May 31.
The relapsing nature of melasma emphasizes the need to maintain efficacy achieved after acute treatment.
To compare clinical efficacy and safety of two 6-month Triple Combination (TC; containing fluocinolone acetonide, hydroquinone and tretinoin) maintenance regimens in subjects with moderate to severe melasma, after daily treatment up to 8 weeks.
This randomized, investigator-blinded, controlled study had a maintenance phase of 6 months. Sixteen centres in Brazil and Mexico enrolled 242 subjects 18 years or older attaining no or mild melasma after 8 weeks of daily TC applications. Subjects were randomized to receive TC in a twice weekly or tapering regimen [3/week (1st month), 2/week (2nd month), 1/week (4th month)]. Efficacy and safety measurements included median time to relapse and relapse-free rate, Global Severity Score, Melasma Area and Severity Index score (MASI), subject's assessment, quality of life questionnaire (MelasQol), and adverse events.
The majority (78.8%) had no or mild melasma (GSS ≤ 1) at week 8 and entered maintenance phase. After 6 months, 53% of patients remained relapse-free with improved quality of life, and time to relapse was similar between groups (about 190 days). Melasma severity at study entry, not maintenance baseline, influenced relapse rate. The twice weekly regimen tended to show better effectiveness in postponing relapse in severe melasma. Both regimens were safe.
After resolution of melasma with TC, maintenance therapy over 6 months was successful in preventing relapse in over half of the patients who entered maintenance phase. Prescribing medicines should be adapted to patients based on melasma severity.
黄褐斑的复发性强调了在急性治疗后保持疗效的必要性。
比较两种 6 个月三联(TC;包含氟轻松醋酸酯、氢醌和维 A 酸)维持方案在 8 周每日治疗后中重度黄褐斑患者中的临床疗效和安全性。
这是一项随机、研究者设盲、对照研究,维持期为 6 个月。巴西和墨西哥的 16 个中心招募了 242 名年龄在 18 岁及以上、8 周每日 TC 应用后无或轻度黄褐斑的患者。受试者随机接受 TC 两周一次或递减方案[每周 3 次(第 1 个月)、每周 2 次(第 2 个月)、每周 1 次(第 4 个月)]。疗效和安全性测量包括复发时间中位数和无复发率、全球严重程度评分、黄褐斑面积和严重程度指数评分(MASI)、患者评估、生活质量问卷(MelasQol)和不良事件。
大多数(78.8%)患者在第 8 周时无或轻度黄褐斑(GSS≤1),进入维持期。6 个月后,53%的患者无复发,生活质量得到改善,且复发时间在两组之间相似(约 190 天)。研究开始时的黄褐斑严重程度而不是维持基线影响复发率。每周两次的方案在延迟严重黄褐斑复发方面似乎更有效。两种方案均安全。
在 TC 治疗黄褐斑消退后,6 个月以上的维持治疗成功地预防了进入维持期的患者中超过一半的复发。应根据黄褐斑的严重程度为患者开处方。