Orthopedic Surgery Department, Annecy Regional Hospital, 1, avenue de l'Hôpital, 74374 Pringy, France.
Orthop Traumatol Surg Res. 2011 Sep;97(5):465-70. doi: 10.1016/j.otsr.2011.01.016. Epub 2011 Jun 2.
Malunion following open reduction and internal fixation of distal radius fracture threatens wrist function. Fixed-angle palmar plates provide rigid fixation that is stable over time; however, the pronator quadratus sectioning required by the anterior approach entails a risk of pronation strength loss and of distal radioulnar joint destabilization. The present study assessed recovery of grip, pronation and supination strength following such internal fixation.
A prospective study included 26 distal radial fractures with dorsal displacement, osteosynthesized using a fixed-angle palmar plate, in 25 patients (mean age: 47.5 years; range: 17-72 years). Assessment concerned the classical parameters, plus grip and pronosupination strength recovery.
At a mean 14 months follow-up (range: 6-30 months), patients had recovered 91% grip strength, 88% pronation strength and 85% supination strength with respect to the healthy side. Complications comprised three cases of malunion, two of reflex sympathetic dystrophy syndrome, and four of post-traumatic carpal tunnel syndrome.
A study of the literature found 75-95% grip strength recovery following osteosynthesis using fixed-angle plates. Few studies, however, have focused on pronosupination strength, and none reported its evolution following osteosynthesis.
The present study found no drawbacks associated with a technique which usually involves sectioning the pronator quadratus. Except in case of malunion or joint stiffness, fixed-angle palmar plate osteosynthesis was followed by recovery of grip and pronosupination strength.
Level IV: prospective non-randomized, non-comparative observational study.
桡骨远端骨折切开复位内固定后出现的畸形愈合会威胁腕关节功能。掌侧固定角钢板可提供稳定的固定,随着时间的推移其稳定性也不会改变;然而,前入路需要切断旋前方肌,这会导致旋前肌力丧失和桡尺远侧关节不稳定的风险。本研究评估了这种内固定后握力、旋前和旋后力量的恢复情况。
一项前瞻性研究纳入了 25 例(平均年龄 47.5 岁;范围 17-72 岁)26 例背侧移位的桡骨远端骨折患者,均采用掌侧固定角钢板进行内固定。评估内容包括经典参数,以及握力和旋前旋后力量的恢复情况。
在平均 14 个月的随访(范围 6-30 个月)中,患者的握力、旋前肌力和旋后肌力相对于健侧分别恢复了 91%、88%和 85%。并发症包括 3 例畸形愈合、2 例反射性交感神经营养不良综合征和 4 例创伤后腕管综合征。
文献研究发现,使用固定角钢板内固定后,握力恢复率为 75%-95%。然而,很少有研究关注旋前旋后力量,也没有研究报告其在骨愈合后的变化。
本研究未发现与通常需要切断旋前方肌的技术相关的缺点。除畸形愈合或关节僵硬外,固定角钢板掌侧内固定后握力和旋前旋后力量均恢复良好。
IV 级:前瞻性非随机、非对照观察性研究。