Chaudhuri Snehamay, Mitra Sankar Nath, Banerjee Pradip Kumar, Biswas Pranab Kumar, Bhattacharyya Sudipta
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, NRS Medical College, Kolkata, West Bengal, India.
J Obstet Gynaecol Res. 2011 Nov;37(11):1564-71. doi: 10.1111/j.1447-0756.2011.01575.x. Epub 2011 Jun 16.
To compare immediate induction with vaginal misoprostol tablets and immediate induction with vaginal dinoprostone (naturally occurring prostaglandin E2 [PGE2]) gel in women with premature rupture of membranes (PROM) at term.
Two hundred and twelve women with PROM at term were assigned randomly to receive either an intravaginal 25 µg misoprostol tablet, 4-hourly, with a maximum of five doses, or 0.5 mg intravaginal PGE2 gel, 6-hourly, with a maximum of two doses. The primary outcome measures were the admission-to-delivery interval and the induction-to-delivery interval. Secondary outcomes included cesarean section rate, mode of delivery, and maternal and neonatal safety outcome. Results were calculated applying Fisher's exact test, χ2-test, t-test and calculating the P-value using an alpha level of 0.05 for Type I errors.
The mean time from admission to delivery was 13.53 h in the misoprostol group and 12.30 h in the PGE2 group (P = 0.090). The induction-to-delivery interval was also comparable between the groups (10.75 h vs. 9.37 h), while the cesarean section rate did not differ significantly between them (7.61% vs. 15.30%). More women in the misoprostol group had an instrumental delivery (12.38% vs. 2.94%). The only significant difference in neonatal outcome was a greater number of babies born with Apgar score < 7 at 1 min in the misoprostol group. Maternal outcomes were not significantly different, except for a higher number of digital vaginal examinations in the misoprostol group.
Vaginal misoprostol is equally efficacious in labor induction and demonstrates a similar fetal and maternal safety profile to PGE2 gel.
比较足月胎膜早破(PROM)女性使用阴道米索前列醇片即刻引产与使用阴道地诺前列酮(天然前列腺素E2 [PGE2])凝胶即刻引产的效果。
212例足月胎膜早破女性被随机分配,分别接受每4小时阴道放置25μg米索前列醇片,最多5剂,或每6小时阴道放置0.5mg PGE2凝胶,最多2剂。主要结局指标为入院至分娩间隔时间和引产至分娩间隔时间。次要结局包括剖宫产率、分娩方式以及母婴安全结局。采用Fisher精确检验、χ2检验、t检验进行结果计算,并使用α水平为0.05的I型错误计算P值。
米索前列醇组从入院到分娩的平均时间为13.53小时,PGE2组为12.30小时(P = 0.090)。两组间引产至分娩间隔时间也相当(10.75小时对9.37小时),而剖宫产率在两组间无显著差异(7.61%对15.30%)。米索前列醇组更多女性采用器械助产(12.38%对2.94%)。新生儿结局的唯一显著差异是米索前列醇组1分钟时阿氏评分<7分的婴儿数量更多。除米索前列醇组阴道指检次数较多外,母婴结局无显著差异。
阴道米索前列醇在引产方面同样有效,并且在胎儿和母亲安全性方面与PGE2凝胶相似。