Am J Bot. 1998 Dec;85(12):1796-802.
The utility of regression and correspondence models for deducing climate from leaf physiognomy was evaluated by the comparative application of different predictive models to the same three leaf assemblages. Mean annual temperature (MAT), mean annual precipitation (MAP), and growing season precipitation (GSP) were estimated from the morphological characteristics of samples of living leaves from two extant forests and an assemblage of fossil leaves. The extant forests are located near Gainesville, Florida, and in the Florida Keys; the fossils were collected from the Eocene Clarno Nut Beds, Oregon. Simple linear regression (SLR), multiple linear regression (MLR), and canonical correspondence analysis (CCA) were used to estimate temperature and precipitation. The SLR models used only the percentage of species having entire leaf margins as a predictor for MAT and leaf size as a predictor for MAP. The MLR models used from two to six leaf characters as predictors, and the CCA used 31 characters. In comparisons between actual and predicted values for the extant forests, errors in prediction of MAT were 0.6°-5.7°C, and errors in prediction of precipitation were 6-89 cm (=6-66%). At the Gainesville site, seven models underestimated MAT and only one overestimated it, whereas at the Keys site, all eight models overestimated MAT. Precipitation was overestimated by all four models at Gainesville, and by three of them at the Keys. The MAT estimates from the Clarno leaf assemblage ranged from 14.3° to 18.8°C, and the precipitation estimates from 227 to 363 cm for MAP and from 195 to 295 cm for GSP.
利用回归和对应模型从叶片形态推断气候的效用,通过对相同的三个叶片组合应用不同的预测模型进行了评估。从两个现生森林和一个化石叶组合的活叶样本的形态特征中估算了年平均温度(MAT)、年平均降水量(MAP)和生长季降水量(GSP)。现生森林位于佛罗里达州盖恩斯维尔附近和佛罗里达群岛;化石则是从俄勒冈州始新世克拉诺坚果床采集的。采用简单线性回归(SLR)、多元线性回归(MLR)和典范对应分析(CCA)来估算温度和降水。SLR 模型仅使用具有全缘叶的物种比例作为 MAT 的预测因子,以及叶面积作为 MAP 的预测因子。MLR 模型使用 2 到 6 个叶片特征作为预测因子,CCA 使用 31 个特征。在现生森林的实际值和预测值之间的比较中,MAT 预测的误差为 0.6°-5.7°C,降水预测的误差为 6-89cm(=6-66%)。在盖恩斯维尔站点,七个模型低估了 MAT,只有一个模型高估了它,而在群岛站点,八个模型都高估了 MAT。四个模型都高估了盖恩斯维尔的降水,其中三个模型高估了群岛的降水。克拉诺叶组合的 MAT 估计值范围为 14.3°-18.8°C,MAP 的降水估计值范围为 227-363cm,GSP 的降水估计值范围为 195-295cm。