Parini Rossella, Corbetta Carlo
Rare Metabolic Diseases Unit, Pediatric Clinic, San Gerardo Hospital, University Milano Bicocca, Monza, Italy.
J Matern Fetal Neonatal Med. 2011 Oct;24 Suppl 2:6-8. doi: 10.3109/14767058.2011.606617.
The advent of tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) around 10 years ago allowed to enlarge consistently the spectrum of metabolic diseases that might be easily and quickly detected. MS/MS was applied to newborn screening in many developed countries, with a wide use, to detect as many as 55 abnormal biochemical conditions (USA), or a restricted one detecting only few diseases (Germany, UK, and Switzerland). Many factors were probably contributing to these very different health organization policies. Although neonatal screening is widely considered extremely useful and efficacious to improve prognosis of many metabolic disorders, the statistically significant demonstration of benefit is quite hard to reach for reasons mainly incidental to the characteristics of these disorders. The expanded newborn screening, in its wide application, includes at present severe diseases presenting in the first days of life, diseases for which treatment is not available, conditions with uncertain significance which are probably not diseases, detection of metabolic disturbances of the mother and all the mildest forms of organic acidurias, urea cycle disorders, fatty acid beta-oxidation defects that may have the possibility to remain asymptomatic for the whole life or may have an acute life-threatening onset of the disease many years later. Which could be the better approach to newborn screening is not clear at present, and probably, it will not be the same for each country. Results of regional screening programs need to be carefully collected and analyzed in future years, with the aim to optimize screening practice in the different countries. Efforts should also be addressed to improve screening programs in the developing countries.
大约10年前串联质谱(MS/MS)技术的出现,使得能够持续扩大可轻松快速检测的代谢性疾病谱。MS/MS已在许多发达国家广泛应用于新生儿筛查,检测多达55种异常生化状况(美国),或仅检测少数疾病的受限项目(德国、英国和瑞士)。许多因素可能导致了这些截然不同的卫生组织政策。尽管新生儿筛查被广泛认为对改善许多代谢紊乱的预后极为有用且有效,但由于这些疾病的特性,很难从统计学上显著证明其益处。目前,广泛应用的扩大新生儿筛查包括出生后几天内出现的严重疾病、尚无治疗方法的疾病、意义不确定可能并非疾病的情况、母亲的代谢紊乱检测以及所有最轻微形式的有机酸尿症、尿素循环障碍、脂肪酸β氧化缺陷,这些疾病可能终生无症状,也可能在多年后急性发病危及生命。目前尚不清楚哪种新生儿筛查方法更好,而且每个国家可能也不尽相同。未来几年需要仔细收集和分析区域筛查项目的结果,以优化不同国家的筛查实践。同时,也应努力改善发展中国家的筛查项目。