Health Services Research, School of Health and Related Research, Regent Court, 30 Regent Street, Sheffield, UK.
Emerg Med J. 2012 Aug;29(8):630-4. doi: 10.1136/emj.2011.111708. Epub 2011 Jul 23.
Whole-body computed tomography (WBCT) is advocated for use in some trauma patients presenting to the emergency department (ED). It is unclear how widespread the use of WBCT is in the UK and the best way to select patients for WBCT remains controversial. The aim of this study was to investigate the current use and nature of WBCT policies in ED in the UK.
A postal questionnaire was devised and distributed to lead doctors of 245 ED in the UK in May 2010. Two further rounds of questionnaires were sent out in June and July to non-responders.
184/245 hospitals responded (75.1%). 41/184 (22.3%) ED had a WBCT policy. 43 (23.4%) further ED indicated that they used WBCT in certain cases, without a formal policy. Hospitals with a WBCT policy saw significantly more trauma cases than those that did not. Most hospitals with a WBCT policy used multiple criteria to decide which patients received WBCT, although there were variations in the timing of CT and in who could request it. Out-of-hours CT scans were less likely to be reported by a consultant radiologist, and reporting times were longer.
The use of WBCT in the UK is variable, although centres that see more trauma seem more likely to have a WBCT policy. The results do raise concerns about how effectively WBCT can be delivered, especially out of hours, but nationwide plans to reorganise trauma care may potentially affect how and at which ED WBCT is offered in the future.
全身计算机断层扫描(WBCT)被提倡用于一些在急诊部(ED)就诊的创伤患者。目前尚不清楚在英国 WBCT 的使用范围有多广,以及选择患者进行 WBCT 的最佳方法仍存在争议。本研究旨在调查英国 ED 中 WBCT 政策的使用现状和性质。
2010 年 5 月,我们设计并向英国 245 家 ED 的主治医生分发了一份邮寄问卷。在 6 月和 7 月,我们向未回复的医生又发送了两轮问卷。
245 家医院中有 184 家(75.1%)做出了回应。其中 41 家(22.3%)ED 有 WBCT 政策。另有 43 家(23.4%)ED 表示他们在某些情况下使用 WBCT,但没有正式的政策。有 WBCT 政策的医院比没有 WBCT 政策的医院看到的创伤患者明显更多。大多数有 WBCT 政策的医院使用多种标准来决定哪些患者接受 WBCT,尽管 CT 的时间和谁可以要求 CT 有所不同。非工作时间的 CT 扫描不太可能由顾问放射科医生报告,而且报告时间更长。
英国 WBCT 的使用情况各不相同,尽管接受更多创伤患者的中心似乎更有可能制定 WBCT 政策。结果确实让人对 WBCT 的有效性提出了担忧,尤其是在非工作时间,但全国范围内重新组织创伤护理的计划可能会影响未来在哪些 ED 提供和如何提供 WBCT。