School of Human Evolution and Social Change, Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ 85287-2402, USA.
School of Human Evolution and Social Change, Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ 85287-2402, USA.
Soc Sci Med. 2011 Aug;73(4):491-497. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2011.05.048. Epub 2011 Jun 22.
Obesity is understood as a major medical and public health challenge, but the stigma attached to it also creates extraordinary suffering. The pervasiveness of morally negative views toward the overweight and obese, such as laziness and lack of self-control, are undeniable in mainstream U.S. society, situated both institutionally (such as health care barriers or media stereotypes) and interpersonally (such as the negative comments of others). To test basic pathways related to the etiology of women's vulnerability to feeling "fat-stigma" in interpersonal relationships, we present a study conducted between August and November 2009 that combines social network, anthropometric, body image, and interview data for 112 women aged 18-45 years, living in Phoenix, Arizona, U.S., and linked follow-up interviews with 823 of their social ties. Based on the proposition that some social network characteristics should amplify the personal experience of stigma, and others should ameliorate it, we ask: what relationship qualities make women more sensitive to the judgments of others about their weight? We find that what others say about women has only a very limited influence on how women judge others' negative views of their weight once actual body size is taken into account, but that women are more influenced by the opinions of those they are closer to and interact with more often. Ultimately, the degree to which women perceive themselves to be judged by others regarding their weight is not well explained by the actual opinions of people in their networks, either known or unknown to them. The assumption that social network norms exert considerable influence on people's stigma experiences needs to be carefully evaluated, at least in the domain of overweight and obesity.
肥胖被认为是一个主要的医学和公共卫生挑战,但与之相关的耻辱感也会造成巨大的痛苦。不可否认,在美国主流社会中,超重和肥胖者普遍受到道德上的负面评价,例如懒惰和缺乏自我控制,这些评价存在于制度层面(例如医疗保健障碍或媒体刻板印象)和人际层面(例如他人的负面评价)。为了测试与女性在人际关系中易感到“肥胖耻辱感”的病因相关的基本途径,我们展示了一项于 2009 年 8 月至 11 月进行的研究,该研究结合了社会网络、人体测量学、身体意象和 112 名 18-45 岁居住在亚利桑那州凤凰城的女性的访谈数据,并与其中 823 名女性社交关系的后续访谈进行了关联。基于一些社会网络特征应该放大个人对耻辱感的体验,而另一些特征应该减轻这种体验的假设,我们提出以下问题:哪些关系质量使女性更容易受到他人对其体重的判断的影响?我们发现,一旦考虑到实际的身体大小,他人对女性的评价对女性如何评价他人对其体重的负面看法只有非常有限的影响,但女性更容易受到与其关系更密切和互动更频繁的人的意见的影响。最终,女性对他人评判自己体重的感知程度并不能很好地解释她们在社交网络中已知或未知的人的实际意见,无论是已知还是未知。社交网络规范对人们的耻辱感体验产生相当大影响的假设需要仔细评估,至少在超重和肥胖领域是如此。