Lachter Jesse, Ben Hur Dana
Department of Gastroenterology, Rambam Health Care Campus, Haifa.
Harefuah. 2011 Jun;150(6):507-11, 553, 552.
Extensive use of colonoscopy has highlighted the need to assess the quality of the procedures in order to reduce costs and increase efficiency.
(1) To assess quality indicators of colonoscopies performed by specialist physicians in Rambam HeaLth Care Campus; (2) To improve the quality of colonoscopies using the data collected.
Data was collected retrospectively from reports of 700 colonoscopies performed by 7 gastroenterology specialists in Rambam Health Care Campus. The data collected was compared to relevant Literature benchmarks for accepted quality indicators.
A total of 95.3% of procedures had appropriate indications. Good or excellent bowel preparation was documented for 57.4% of procedures with a range for individual physicians from 18.2%-84%. Completion rate was 92.4% (range 89.9%-97%). Overall polyp detection rate was 29.1% (range 17%-45%). Polyp detection rate in screening colonoscopies was 13.2% for women and 26.1% for men. Biopsies were taken in 90.3% of colonoscopies performed for inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) follow-up and in 75% of colonoscopies performed in patients with chronic diarrhea. Follow-up recommendations were noted in 82.6% of procedures with any indication for follow-up (range 70%-92.5%).
Colonoscopies are performed in Rambam Health Care Campus in an effective manner with regard to completion rate and polyp detection. High rates of intermediate or poor bowel preparation, suboptimal rates of taking biopsies and making follow-up recommendations were noted. Significant variations among participating physicians were noted. Conclusions led to operative changes in practice, including improving computerized reports, standardizing assessments of preparation and initiating a continuous quality improvement program.
结肠镜检查的广泛应用凸显了评估检查质量以降低成本和提高效率的必要性。
(1)评估兰巴姆医疗保健校园内科专家进行的结肠镜检查的质量指标;(2)利用收集的数据提高结肠镜检查的质量。
回顾性收集兰巴姆医疗保健校园7位胃肠病学专家进行的700例结肠镜检查报告中的数据。将收集到的数据与公认质量指标的相关文献基准进行比较。
总共95.3%的检查有适当的适应证。57.4%的检查记录了良好或优秀的肠道准备情况,个别医生的比例范围为18.2%-84%。完成率为92.4%(范围89.9%-97%)。总体息肉检出率为29.1%(范围17%-45%)。筛查结肠镜检查中,女性息肉检出率为13.2%,男性为26.1%。在90.3%的用于炎症性肠病(IBD)随访的结肠镜检查以及75%的慢性腹泻患者的结肠镜检查中进行了活检。在82.6%有任何随访指征的检查中记录了随访建议(范围70%-92.5%)。
兰巴姆医疗保健校园进行的结肠镜检查在完成率和息肉检出方面是有效的。注意到肠道准备处于中等或较差水平的比例较高,活检和提出随访建议的比例未达最佳。参与检查的医生之间存在显著差异。这些结论导致了实际操作的改变,包括改进计算机化报告、规范准备情况评估并启动持续质量改进计划。