Hoffmann Paul J
University of New England College of Osteopathic Medicine, MA, USA.
J Am Osteopath Assoc. 2011 Jul;111(7):445-9.
Living organ donors are growing in number and account for a substantial proportion of organs transplanted. Types of living organ donors include family members, anonymous donors, and friends. Although familial donation is the most common form of living organ donation, anonymous donation and donation among friends are gaining popularity. Society has placed living organ donors at the top of the altruistic ladder. However, one's altruistic motives for living organ donation may be affected by the type of relationship he or she has with the organ recipient. Although family relationships are close, pressure and coercion from family members may make informed consent difficult. Anonymous donors do not have the pressure associated with a familial donation, but psychological and self-worth issues may influence their choice to donate. Friendship incorporates the close relationships associated with familial donation and the freedom associated with anonymous donation. Using Aristotle's definition of true friendship, the author argues that best friends are the only true altruistic living organ donors and therefore may be preferable to family donors or anonymous donors.
活体器官捐赠者的数量正在增加,并且在器官移植中占相当大的比例。活体器官捐赠者的类型包括家庭成员、匿名捐赠者和朋友。虽然亲属捐赠是活体器官捐赠最常见的形式,但匿名捐赠和朋友间的捐赠也越来越普遍。社会将活体器官捐赠者置于利他主义的最高层级。然而,一个人进行活体器官捐赠的利他动机可能会受到其与器官接受者关系类型的影响。尽管家庭关系密切,但家庭成员的压力和强迫可能会使知情同意变得困难。匿名捐赠者没有亲属捐赠所带来的压力,但心理和自我价值问题可能会影响他们的捐赠选择。友谊兼具亲属捐赠所具有的亲密关系以及匿名捐赠所具有的自由。作者运用亚里士多德对真正友谊的定义,认为最好的朋友是唯一真正利他的活体器官捐赠者,因此可能比亲属捐赠者或匿名捐赠者更可取。